News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MesaLink: A memory-safe and OpenSSL-compatible TLS library by tptacek on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @01:34PM (#16747040)
While I agree that Chinese sponsorship is not a good reason to avoid a library, every part of the reasoning in this comment is bad.

For most people, the threat model that focuses on FVEY includes China (China is a key part of FVEY's remit). If China has backdoored something, the FVEY threat model assumes FVEY has it too.

In particular: while FVEY governments theoretically have local legal limitations to their collection capabilities, they have no formal limitations to foreign collections --- foreign collections are the entire point of SIGINT agencies. Moving your data overseas to hide it from the NSA is thus, ceteris paribus, an extremely dumb idea.

Further, it is extremely difficult to extract cryptographic weaknesses from software, and relative to the scale of the whole problem, source code availability is a marginal factor. If you're going to say "identify all those backdoors", you might just as well say "YOLO".

Re:MesaLink: A memory-safe and OpenSSL-compatible TLS library by jessaustin on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @02:10PM (#16747446)
We have different understandings of threats from "FVEY". I don't assume that e.g. FBI uses China's putative backdoors when trolling for subjects to oppress. In comparison, China is using them for precisely that purpose; this is the hypothesis from which this discussion started. There simply isn't much intersection between the two sets of oppressed subjects.

FBI might know of some such backdoors, if they exist, but there is no structural reason to expect that they do. FVEY is not a monolith. If there were a "national security" reason to be interested in some target, that might inspire enough cooperation to generate a Baidu vuln. Most subjects, however, are simply targets of opportunity for law enforcement, with no real connection to national security.

Sure, YOLO, but TFA is a repo. That is a pure thing, the worth of which is totally unrelated to all this other stuff.