News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wristband Lets the Brain Control a Computer with a Though... by yorwba on Sunday April 01, 2018 @10:46PM (#16731930)
Right, nobody is going to learn how to type on a keyboard when they could just write with a pen. /s

Interfaces are supposed to make things easier, but they are not required to improve every possible application. If this interface makes just some things easier or possible at all, it will be a win.

Using a camera would require mounting it somewhere where it can see the hand at all times, which precludes mobile uses. There's also the problem of exhausting yourself by using gestural interfaces for too long, where just minimal muscle twitches would probably be more comfortable.

Re:Wristband Lets the Brain Control a Computer with a Though... by fallous on Monday April 02, 2018 @01:51AM (#16732605)
Interfaces are not necessarily supposed to make things easier, they're supposed to allow the user to achieve things that they otherwise could not do (there is no easing of "can't do it") or that they otherwise had to exert decidedly more effort in attaining results than the effort of learning the interface (there is an easing, but it's tied to the cost of change/learning). If you can't meet the bar of those criteria you should always revert to the principle of least surprise.
Re:Wristband Lets the Brain Control a Computer with a Though... by taneq on Monday April 02, 2018 @07:25PM (#16740400)
> (there is no easing of "can't do it")

On the contrary, if something is impossible then making it possible most certainty makes it easier!

Re:Wristband Lets the Brain Control a Computer with a Though... by fallous on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @12:07AM (#16741845)
"I am able to do X." "It is now easier for you to be able to do X." "I am unable to do X." "It is now easier for you to be unable to do X." The latter makes no sense. Moving from the impossible to the possible isn't an easing, it's a fundamental change in the nature of a thing.
Re:Wristband Lets the Brain Control a Computer with a Though... by taneq on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @12:36AM (#16741949)
Depends on your definitions, I guess. If you define "easier" as "decreases the difficulty of doing X" then it makes sense as you've reduced an infinite difficulty down to a finite difficulty.
Re:Wristband Lets the Brain Control a Computer with a Though... by fallous on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @09:26AM (#16744383)
Note you changed the nature of the problem by turning "infinite difficulty" into "finite difficulty." Subtract all the difficulty you want from "infinite" and you still end up with infinite, unless of course you subtract infinite difficulty from it... which means you qualitatively changed it from infinite difficulty to merely difficult.
Re:Wristband Lets the Brain Control a Computer with a Though... by wyattpeak on Sunday April 01, 2018 @11:03PM (#16731999)
Hmm, you're right about keyboards. My gut still says that learning a new interface is an unlikely thing to expect of consumers, but it'll obviously need more thought.

My issue certainly isn't with interfaces being easier for all things, I was challenging that this benefited in any substantial situation at all, but I'll concede my point until and unless I refine my argument about people being unwilling to invest effort in a new interface.

Re:Wristband Lets the Brain Control a Computer with a Though... by anonytrary on Monday April 02, 2018 @01:30AM (#16732538)
The same could have been (and was) said about the personal computer in the 70s! While this exact wristband may not replace keyboards, I think biological interfaces are definitely worth researching. All it takes is a kid creating a beautiful painting or piece of music with a new tool to start the snowball effect.

That said, the theremin was a new musical interface and didn't ever take off because it produced a strange sound quality and did not map well to preexisting human motions. Furthermore, music creation was already well understood.

Indeed, machines need to be built for the human, not the other way around. I think it's a trade off between two terms: how easy the interface is to learn and what it enables us to do. For (a contrived) example, an interface which allows humans to teleport will be learned regardless of how steep the learning curve is. Teleportation is a "zero to one" technology, it more or less competes with nothing. A new kind of keyboard on the other hand, must compete with the existing solution for keyboards, so it must be easy to learn, otherwise there would be no incentive to switch.