Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient...
by gus_massa on Sunday April 01, 2018 @10:54PM
(#16731950)
I've read too many papers published in peer review journals where a tiny advance is sold like a groundbreaking game changing advance, so I'm very difficult to impress.
The most popular cases of overstatement are the improvement of the batteries life and the cure of cancer. but there are similar bad reporting in less popular fields.
In this case it's easy to decide. We can just wait until April 1st 2033 and see if there is a tokamak fusion reactor that can break even without creative accounting.
Both: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KkpqA8yG9T4&t=32m35s
This work is being done by the head of MIT's Nuclear Science department, in collaboration with most of the top grad students there. You can go look through all the publications that have resulted. They're going into great detail with practical engineering concerns, not just vague concept.
It's really disappointing and frustrating to me to see all the shallow dismissals here. The original article/press release didn't have much concrete information. But instead of making the reasonable assumption that some of the best people in the field actually know what they're talking about, and the article is poor, instead HN commenters are deciding their zero content, zero knowledge, shallow dismissals are more likely than what the experts are saying.
Nearly all the information about the ARC project is out there in the literature. If you don't want to read it that's fine, just try to have some awareness that you can't dismiss things without actually knowing what they are.