Because if it is, the white people should be pulled over at least 3x times more.
Another thing I dot understand: when a cop pulls over a vehicle, how is it possible for the cop to know if the car is being driven by a black person or not? so, it is possible that of all those pulled over, a greater %age of black drivers get ticketed for smaller infractions.
Kind of drives home the point.
No it's not. The chart says that a black driver has approximately a 3x greater chance of being stopped than a white driver, which seems consistent with your numbers.
I'm not sure that going by overall population is useful. There are at least two problems with it, when looking at being pulled over while driving.
1. Age distributions need to be taken into account. I don't know if this applies to Montana, but I believe that in some states there are noticeable differences in age distribution between races. At the very least, you want to limit it to just people who are old enough drive.
2. Wealth distribution needs to be taken into account. In most states blacks are on average less wealthy than whites. I would expect that means that white families are more likely than black families to have more than one car. I would expect that to result in disproportionately more white driven car trips than black driven car trips.
You really need to go by what police are seeing on the roads: what percent of the cars that a police officer sees are white driven and what percent are black driven? That's loosely correlated with general population race distribution, but there are several filters including those described above between that and cars on the road that change the distribution.
Do you think this isn't true? I don't know one way or another, but I think if National Geographic is going to make such a claim they'd have made some effort to verify it.
How is someone who is not able (or maybe not bothered) to assess this claim themselves from raw data, supposed to know what to believe?
Is there a good way to compare these claims?
(For the record I did check the numbers in the parent post myself)
https://openpolicing.stanford.edu/data/
Opening the Montana dataset in Pandas you can see:
So we can already see that there were 85x more whites being pulled over than blacks, which is the opposite of what their chart was suggesting. That is not very surprising since according to the census, whites made up 87.8% of the Montana population while blacks made up 0.4%. When accounting for population difference, you get numbers similar to what they claimed, though they fail to mention this in the presentation. "Traffic stops for white and black Americans per 100 driving-age people, 2015 (where data is available)"How much of this article can be trusted? It seems to be filled with a lot of appeals to emotion, and misleading charts.