Re:Million-dollar Strads fall to modern violins in blind ‘so...
by Retric on Saturday March 31, 2018 @04:30AM
(#16722372)
I don't see any reason to limit yourself to imitation. Build a better violin and and you get a better violin. Imitate a Stradivari and you get something that sounds like a Stradivari, but does not improve upon the original.
It's the original that contributes not only to sound but to the perception of the performance, because of the years that have gone by since the instruments first incarnation.
Of course, if you do it in a blind test, you aswell could simulate all the previously scanned stradivari properties, but that doesn't keep the original from being superior in idea - because it's the _original_.
YES, we can build quasi-stradivaris en masse now, but that doesn't keep the originals from being superior.
Therefore one of the main purposes of the Stradivari Violin is to show it, and announce it as such in a performance.
It's a historic thing with these instruments, not an engineering minmaxing thing.