News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Internal Facebook posts of employees discussing leaked memo by heavenlyblue on Friday March 30, 2018 @10:49AM (#16716527)
Theranos have innovated themselves to oblivion. We must learn that there's a definite line between innovating and blatantly generating noise for the sake of new noise (also supported by inverstors).
Re:Internal Facebook posts of employees discussing leaked memo by epmaybe on Friday March 30, 2018 @11:25AM (#16716848)
This seems incorrect because as far as I know Theranos didn't innovate. Their machines didn't work, did they?
Re:Internal Facebook posts of employees discussing leaked memo by heavenlyblue on Friday March 30, 2018 @11:30AM (#16716894)
How do you tell Theranos from not-Theranos before you'd invested a bunch of money in them?

As far as we know there were quite a few large players in the industry who were uninterested in Theranos - which means they have rejected their ideas before the ideas came into living.

Re:Internal Facebook posts of employees discussing leaked memo by bkohlmann on Friday March 30, 2018 @11:16AM (#16716757)
Societal utility is a weighted average. Any worthwhile process will have positive and negative outcomes. Those that endure will provide greater upside than downside.

I believe that a process where any idea is given consideration is preferable to one in which ideas are suppressed. We need all the "bad" ideas to discover the "good" ones.

Re:Internal Facebook posts of employees discussing leaked memo by bkohlmann on Friday March 30, 2018 @01:51PM (#16718270)
I'm perplexed by the downvotes. So I can refine my understanding, I'd love to know where I'm thinking incorrectly. Here is what I think are the possible counters to what I proposed:

1) Societal utility is NOT a weighted average - namely, an acceptable outcome will only have positive externalities.

2) Processes in which ideas are suppressed are in general preferable to those in which ideas can be unconstrained

3) We can discover the full set of "good" ideas without being exposed to "bad" ideas

Where else is the disagreement coming from? What are your insights that lead you to reject what I've proposed?

Re:Internal Facebook posts of employees discussing leaked memo by heavenlyblue on Friday March 30, 2018 @11:28AM (#16716868)
A process where any idea is always given consideration is naturally highly vulnerable to sybil attacks.

For example, there's a reason why once upon a time we had agreed (as a society) to never accept any new potents for perpetual motion machines - because the only ideas that were left are the bad ones, and we can prove it.

Now if there comes a time in history when the laws of physics suddenly discover something new - we may re-approach our decision. But I don't think many educated people believe it's going to happen anytime soon.

Re:Internal Facebook posts of employees discussing leaked memo by bkohlmann on Friday March 30, 2018 @01:54PM (#16718290)
That's the point though - we only know that perpetual motion machines are not yet possible because nearly every testable idea we've come up yields nothing. Our system is better for allowing, and dismissing, bad ideas than never allowing them at all.
Re:Internal Facebook posts of employees discussing leaked memo by mrgordon on Friday March 30, 2018 @04:15PM (#16719464)
I'm not sure where you're going with this. Facebook allowed these terrible ideas to proliferate which is why we have lost our privacy and rights to "subtle language" and "questionable policies." Now people are acting like the choice is between allowing these ideas or not allowing them.

In reality, its much more nuanced. It turns out a lot of people think the ideas are horrible, offensive, and immoral. Thus Facebook can continue to embrace these ideas and lose employees and public respect, or they can not embrace these ideas and hopefully recover some reputation. It isn't about "disallowing" these ideas. Its about not building a business around screwing people over if you don't want to be known for screwing people over. Something can be allowed without memos from top ranking managers dictating that this is the way the business runs (and will run in the future in China)

Re:Internal Facebook posts of employees discussing leaked memo by BlackFingolfin on Friday March 30, 2018 @11:28AM (#16716871)
Innovated? More like blatantly lied and committed fraud, I'd say
Re:Internal Facebook posts of employees discussing leaked memo by heavenlyblue on Friday March 30, 2018 @11:34AM (#16716934)
So you'd agree with the fact that sometimes calling someone on their bullshit before giving them money is a viable strategy?

I had to put "innovated" in quotation marks - I meant it in a symbolic way: "innovation is what Theranos were selling to their investors and then they either realised they could not deliver or they have blatantly lied from the beginning".