News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Qatar's F-15s Will Feature New 'Low Profile' Heads Up Dis... by jacquesm on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:34PM (#16712599)
Not a pilot but like you I can't stand them cars. Tactile means I can keep my eyes on the road, which is the only thing that matters while driving. I found myself glancing at the screen before touching it and got rid of the touchscreen only device that was in my car and replaced it with something that has the major functions under a button. And I don't use it for navigation, I have a dedicated device for that I've placed on the right of the rear view mirror.

Airplanes have to deal with turbulence and I really would not want to change any critical settings on a touch screen while being bounced around, I remember when I still had the bloody touchscreen device in the car I mis-touched and I had no idea how to get back to where it was before, it took a stop at a gas station to reset the interface. In general I think the obsession with getting rid of knobs and buttons is a bad thing.

I'd love it if there was a general prohibition on touch screens in cars, I'm pretty sure that it is a safety issue. Any device that requires that you take your eyes of the road in a vehicle is a bad device.

Re:Qatar's F-15s Will Feature New 'Low Profile' Heads Up Dis... by forgotmypw on Thursday March 29, 2018 @10:41PM (#16713265)
[ Shoot ] [ Eject ]

... tries to tap the Shoot button, but the plane shakes. Eject button is tapped instead ...

"Fuck!"

Ejecting will render plane not usable, are you sure? [ Yes ] [ Cancel ]

... taps Cancel very carefully ...

You have chosen to Cancel the ejection process, but you don't have enough coins! [Purchase Coins] [Cancel and Eject]

Re:Qatar's F-15s Will Feature New 'Low Profile' Heads Up Dis... by jacquesm on Thursday March 29, 2018 @11:24PM (#16713451)
Do you want to drop engines 1-4?

[yes] [ask me again in 30 seconds]

Re:Qatar's F-15s Will Feature New 'Low Profile' Heads Up Dis... by forgotmypw on Friday March 30, 2018 @12:05AM (#16713596)
Please turn off Airplane Mode to continue. [Eject]
Re:Qatar's F-15s Will Feature New 'Low Profile' Heads Up Dis... by skocznymroczny on Friday March 30, 2018 @08:42AM (#16715611)
This plane has new updates available. The operating system shall reboot now. Hopefully you're not in flight right now.
Re:Qatar's F-15s Will Feature New 'Low Profile' Heads Up Dis... by jacquesm on Friday March 30, 2018 @09:20AM (#16715804)
Don't even joke about that: OTA updates in mobility applications is a thing and not everybody in that space is smart enough to only do this when the vehicle is stationary.
Re:Qatar's F-15s Will Feature New 'Low Profile' Heads Up Dis... by VLM on Friday March 30, 2018 @09:43AM (#16715947)
I'm waiting for the first aviation GPS nav system to pull the automobile trick and refuse to accept programming while in flight. "Sorry you may not select an emergency landing airfield as a new destination, the aircraft is in flight, please land the aircraft then for your safety the GPS configuration screen will be unlocked". Its merely obnoxious nanny when a car driver is alone, but its incredibly frustrating when the car or airplane has a "copilot" dedicated to the task.
Re:Qatar's F-15s Will Feature New 'Low Profile' Heads Up Dis... by jacquesm on Friday March 30, 2018 @10:32AM (#16716383)
There's a bit of a difference between you changing your destination vs the manufacturer updating the software while the vehicle is in motion.

A really good voice interface would be a solution here. But I'd want to that to be 'on device', not through some service where the audio gets sent.

Fortunately avionics tend to be better behaved than car electronics but there are plenty of people bitching about the latest generation of touch screen hardware in general aviation planes.

Nice stackexchange thread about this:

https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/22729/why-are-t...

Re:Qatar's F-15s Will Feature New 'Low Profile' Heads Up Dis... by mkempe on Thursday March 29, 2018 @09:03PM (#16712762)
I agree. Even with force feedback I don't think these interfaces will ever be as good as physical knobs, buttons, and sliders. "Good" in the sense that they can be reached, perceived, and manipulated with our senses completely without eyesight. For instance I recently drove a Volvo V90 (every control on a large flat screen) and the climate control for seat heating was tiny and slow to update -- I had to take my eyes off the road to find it, aim at the specific setting I wanted, and wait to see whether the setting had changed as intended; by contrast in my current Volvo V60 there are physical buttons that I press (without aiming because I know exactly where each one is) and they instantly change the settings as desired.
Re:Qatar's F-15s Will Feature New 'Low Profile' Heads Up Dis... by crististm on Friday March 30, 2018 @06:58AM (#16715126)
Real knobs have built-in force feedback and none of the disadvantages of touch buttons. I have no idea what it will take the industry to realize the sub-optimality of touch environment.
Re:Qatar's F-15s Will Feature New 'Low Profile' Heads Up Dis... by digi_owl on Friday March 30, 2018 @09:51AM (#16716021)
I high end brand going on a retro binge...
Re:Qatar's F-15s Will Feature New 'Low Profile' Heads Up Dis... by domevent on Thursday March 29, 2018 @09:09PM (#16712788)
Could haptic feedback be “granular” enough to mimic specific shapes of knobs and switches?
Re:Qatar's F-15s Will Feature New 'Low Profile' Heads Up Dis... by pasbesoin on Thursday March 29, 2018 @09:44PM (#16712957)
Introduce vibration. Physical controls give you a topology to orient to. A flat screen doesn't.

Every control becomes an exercise in sustained hand-eye coordination.

Talk about your distracted driving -- or flying.

Can haptic feedback really help with that? (Serious question: I haven't had the opportunity.)

Re:Qatar's F-15s Will Feature New 'Low Profile' Heads Up Dis... by mkempe on Thursday March 29, 2018 @11:31PM (#16713477)
That's one crucial aspect of the problem. My fingers can navigate across physical controls, simply using my sense of touch, without triggering any of them until I exert sufficient pressure. Could this be emulated in theory with haptic feedback? possibly, but nobody is offering such flat-screen UIs at the moment.
Re:Qatar's F-15s Will Feature New 'Low Profile' Heads Up Dis... by digi_owl on Friday March 30, 2018 @09:53AM (#16716036)
One reason i actually liked resistive screens, because i could rest my fingers on it without triggering anything.
Re:Qatar's F-15s Will Feature New 'Low Profile' Heads Up Dis... by dkersten on Friday March 30, 2018 @01:15AM (#16713860)
Probably. I’ve experienced a haptic device that made it feel like I was pushing my hand through sand, so making it feel like knobs and switches must be possible. I also remember seeing something once where haptic feedback was used to make a flat surface feel like a keyboard.