News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by s2g on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @04:33PM (#16701643)
You fully support a propaganda agency?
[dead]
Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by jacquesm on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @05:22PM (#16702076)
> Most of what comes out of US mainstream media is propaganda.

No, it isn't. There is a lot of pretty good journalism and then there is a bunch of trash. But the balance - for now - is still on the good side. If Rupert Murdoch kicked the bucket it might get a bit better still.

> I support alternate sources in conjunction with those.

Such as?

FOX vs Russia Today is not 'alternate' by any definition.

But if you want to compare the Washington Post with the BBC or Al Jazeera then you might find some balance between those.

> What I don't support is getting all your info from a single narrative.

Agreed, but which narratives you pick still makes a huge difference even when you are trying to discount for bias.

> Edit: there are obviously a lot of brainwashed people or actual agents in this thread doing some unfair downvoting.

Or maybe they just don't subscribe to your views and are letting you know their disagreement by downvoting you.

If you think HN is full of brainwashed people or actual agents because of a couple of downvotes I suspect the problem is on your end.

Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by colordrops on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @06:57PM (#16702815)
Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by jacquesm on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @06:18PM (#16702542)
I've actually read manufacturing consent and while I agree with the general idea that everything that we consume is propaganda to some degree I disagree that CNN is at the same level as Pravda in Russia.

There is definitely a case to be made for mass media being complicit in all this but not to the extent that actual propaganda mechanisms are put to work. The state does not own CNN, it does not own the Washington Post and it does not own the Guardian. Ironically, it does own the BBC and there are definitely times when you just knew that there was more to a story than what you could read but on the whole the 'manufacturing of consent' is not the same as outright propaganda.

For that you'd have to take a step back and look at some actual propaganda to see the difference. In the United States FOX comes pretty close (though not their 'hard news' section, that is still more or less factual), in Russia there are the various state owned media outlets and in China everything that the party sanctioned press will print would count as propaganda.

The rest of the media can - still, and who knows for how much longer - be held to a slightly higher standard.

Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by colordrops on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @06:29PM (#16702623)
You are moving the goalposts. We aren't talking about Pravda, we are talking about Russia Today, and we aren't talking about how bad the propaganda is, but whether it is propaganda at all.

Also, you are misunderstanding how propaganda works in the US if you think the outlet needs to be state owned. I suggest the following article:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverted_totalitarianism#Compa...

Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by jacquesm on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @06:38PM (#16702672)
I definitely consider Russia Today as a propaganda mouthpiece of the Russian State. I have no illusions about being able to operate something like Russia Today without permission from the state.

As for the state of affairs in the USA: I believe the USA is fundamentally broken in many ways. Born from violence and with an extreme focus on money in all aspects of life it has some pretty bad elements that amount to legalized corruption. The MIC, the number of people imprisoned, the two party system, the evangelical element, American exceptionalism, the fun fetish, the power of lobbyists, the power of money in elections all amount to flaws that each individually could be fatal, and that collectively are a ticking time bomb under the most powerful country in the world.

Which way that will go is anybody's guess, I personally am horrified that someone like Trump could make it to the position of president of the USA, but then again, if Ronald Reagan could then why not someone even less qualified?

Time will tell where it is all headed, but - in spite of you r links - I refuse to believe that all American media are complicit in this, even though I do believe that they could do a much better job at keeping the politicians sharp.

[dead]
Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by jacquesm on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @05:48PM (#16702310)
> The only acceptable stance on HN is rabid and unsubstantiated Russiaphobia.

That is simply not true.

[dead]
Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by jacquesm on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @06:13PM (#16702499)
Well, I'm pretty outspoken and I have a general anti-corporate streak running through me and I do not like the way the USA has comported itself on the world stage since 9/11 much. They had all the credit that they could possibly wish for and they totally fucked it up. The fact that my comments in that vein are not categorically downvoted (rather the opposite) should be a pretty strong proof that it is definitely possible to walk your own course on HN without being harassed. Where HN draws the line is: stuff that is unsourced or plainly made up or crackpot, falsehoods and apologist stuff. That will get you downvoted in a hurry.
Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by colordrops on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @06:36PM (#16702666)
There is no concrete evidence made publicly available whatsoever in the Russia hysteria that has been going on for 18 months. Bernie Sanders, Julian Assange, Edward Snowden, Jill Stein, Glenn Greenwald, and anyone who criticizes the left at all, even if they are leftist themselves, get called Russian stooges at this point.

It's too much:

https://theintercept.com/2017/09/28/yet-another-major-russia...

Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by jacquesm on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @06:46PM (#16702731)
You're aware that a whole bunch of people have already been indicted and have admitted guilt?

At this point in time the 'Russia hysteria' is on pretty solid footing, the question is not whether or not there is something there but how high up it goes and who knew what and when.

Manafort will almost certainly end up being convicted and whether or not he will spend the rest of his life in jail hinges on Trump's ability to pardon him.

Whoever calls Sanders, Assange, Snowdon Stein and Greenwald a Russian Stooge has a problem, but that's not my problem.

The real issue is that even though none of them are with any likelihood - as far as I can see at the moment - Russian stooges does not mean that there are no Russian stooges. And if you put Manafort and Gates in there and listed Assange, Papadopoulos and mr. van der Zwaan in there as useful idiots I would probably agree with the list.

Incidentally, Greenwald is doing a pretty good job at keeping an even keel in general, and I totally support his debunking bogus claims. But that does not mean that all claims are bogus.

Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by colordrops on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @06:59PM (#16702830)
But what have they been indicted on? Tell me exactly the charges.
Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by jacquesm on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @07:06PM (#16702886)
Do your own homework:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_Counsel_investigation_...

If you have been following this at all then none of this should be news to you, if you haven't been following this then I do not understand some of the positions you have been taking in this thread.

Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by colordrops on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @07:24PM (#16703025)
No, do your own homework. You can't ask others to prove a negative. By the link you provided yourself, there is nothing in there about any indictments regarding collusion with Russia to interfere with the US election.
Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by jacquesm on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @07:44PM (#16703163)
I think you fail to understand how a typical special counsel investigation works.

So the fact that there are no indictments regarding to collusion to Russia at this point in time means absolutely nothing. But if there still are no such indictments when it is all over it would be safe to conclude there was no such thing.

Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by colordrops on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @07:47PM (#16703187)
Yes, but since there is no public evidence, and no indictments, why is the mainstream media pumping this russia fear narrative non-stop for the last 18 months? That's the topic of this thread. Why is everyone so damn sure of the truth when there is no evidence or charges?

You said in this thread:

> You're aware that a whole bunch of people have already been indicted and have admitted guilt?

No they haven't.

Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by jacquesm on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @08:21PM (#16703414)
Because you can safely assume that if it has happened whoever did it did not leave a box and a card with a pointer saying 'smoking gun'. Have some patience, it will all come out in time, either way. For now there is a whole lot more evidence that at least some people didn't mind playing fast and loose with the truth and that alone should be cause enough for worry. And no, none of that is 'the topic of this thread', you made it that, the topic of this thread is Assange losing comms privileges.

And the media isn't pumping any 'fear' narrative, it is for the most part reporting that which is either leaked or found in court documents.

So, nobody is 'damn sure of the truth', and neither are you and no evidence or charges does not mean there won't be any. Or do you mean to say the investigation should be closed before it has run its course because you think there never will be any charges? And if that's true what does it matter? In that case you should want it to conclude because that is the only way this thing will go away in a way that it will stay away.

[dead]
Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by jacquesm on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @08:51PM (#16703603)
I'm saying that with a straight face because I'm not feeling any 'fear' from whatever the media wrote. If you feel fear that's your problem, not mine. Russiagate is a pretty apt description, and any comparison with PEARL HARBOR would seem to be historically pretty inaccurate, even if it is all true, which remains to be seen. But there is more than just a little bit of smoke, let's hope there is no fire because if there is a fire and hard proof is obtained it will have vast consequences. Better hope it all isn't true that would be the best outcome.
Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by grzm on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @07:02PM (#16702850)
Is your point that there are no charges or that the charges are irrelevant? Something else? Rather than argue for the sake of argument, if you know something, put it on the table and move the ball forward.
Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by colordrops on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @07:33PM (#16703093)
My point is that there are no indictments on anything related to collusion with Russians to interfere wit US elections.
Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by grzm on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @07:46PM (#16703176)
> "collusion with Russians to interfere wit US elections."

While others may make that claim, and it would be included in the scope of the investigation, that's not its only remit. Nor, from my reading, does 'jacquesm make that claim. But he can argue his case better than I.

Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by robotrout on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @04:40PM (#16701714)
Sure, I support BBC which has a very strong propaganda to news ratio. I also support RT and Al Jazeera. I do not support CNN, because it's ratio is so high it's offensive to me.
Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by colordrops on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @06:17PM (#16702536)
An unfortunate element of propaganda is that it is designed to not be detected by the majority of those receiving it, as evidenced by the down votes you are receiving. I don't understand how the HN crowd which is clearly full of very intelligent people don't see that sources like BBC and CNN are clearly propaganda outlets.
Re:Ecuador cuts off Julian Assange's internet access at Lond... by cinquemb on Friday March 30, 2018 @04:30AM (#16714619)
At some point an individual has to decide whether to try to fight the beliefs and behaviors of others, or to exploit that they hold/engage in such for some ends.