News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Has a Striking History of Bias Against Black Girls by jacquesm on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @02:59PM (#16700688)
> Google search results reflect what's in use on the web via PageRank and modern PageRank-like approximations.

PageRank is only a fraction of the total inputs to Google search. Once PageRank was described it was subject to being gamed at such a scale that it essentially destroyed the web, ironically making Google that much more a necessity.

> Google and its human staff does not apply human intellect to the problem of sorting, picking, and ranking each search result.

Yes they do. By tweaking the weights of certain output categories (such as evidenced in the article, a clear drop in the number of pornographic or semi pornographic results as a result of such a tweak) there is a large amount of influence exerted on the results.

> Moreover, Google has included "Safe Search" features for several years that would remove these types of results from search.

Safe search always was a weird one: You'd expect the opposite, a 'smut search' (Tom Lehrer would have a field day with that one).

> Before we condemn Google for the collective actions of the broader Internet community of websites (and the author's step of disabling Safe Search), we should take a moment to understand this point.

Before we invalidate the authors point by handwaving and purposefully injecting chaff into the conversation let's try to understand the actual point they are trying to make: That a query for an innocent term such as 'black girls' even with 'safe search off' should not result in a bunch of porn.

> Now, it is possible to create a search engine curated by humans or filters that remove objectionable content, and perhaps that approach might be desirable to some - a "MyGoogle" experience with search results customized based on Google's interpretation (or explicit settings) of the author's demographics, political beliefs, trigger words, and purchase history.

That's nothing to do with the authors point.

Re:Google Has a Striking History of Bias Against Black Girls by politician on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @03:26PM (#16700996)
> That a query for an innocent term...

I take strong issue with the "obvious" conclusion that Google knows which terms are innocent. Disclaimer: In this specific case, I agree with you that "black girls" has an innocent connotation and am not suggesting otherwise. Please do not misinterpret my thoughts below.

Shall we require Google to be ever vigilant about the meaning of words in use at various times by the various communities of the world, and to entrust them with the responsibility for determining the innocence or guiltiness of words or phrases for all mankind?

If we shall require such effort of Google, ought we not elevate Google to the role of judge over other matters of humankind given their good stewardship over matters of innocence and guilt?

Taken to the limit the argument advocates the establishment of an echo chamber to wrap tightly around each one's subjective interpretation of their reality. Isn't this the exact opposite of what we should be trying to achieve?

Have we not had enough of this Brave New World?

Re:Google Has a Striking History of Bias Against Black Girls by jacquesm on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @03:45PM (#16701180)
> Shall we require Google to be ever vigilant about the meaning of words in use at various times by the various communities of the world, and to entrust them with the responsibility for determining the innocence or guiltiness of words or phrases for all mankind?

Google aims to 'organize the worlds information', how it does that concerns all of us so yes, this makes them responsible with determining whether a certain set of words has an innocent or negative interpretation.

It's not the world I want to live in but I live in it nonetheless. That Google should not have this power to begin with is obvious but here we are.

> If we shall require such effort of Google, ought we not elevate Google to the role of judge over other matters of humankind given their good stewardship over matters of innocence and guilt?

Definitely not, why make things even worse? They already have too much power we will not make things better by compounding the problem.

> Taken to the limit the argument advocates the establishment of an echo chamber to wrap tightly around each one's subjective interpretation of their reality. Isn't this the exact opposite of what we should be trying to achieve?

It is, but again, the filter bubble is real and the more customized Google search results are for an individual the worse this gets.

> Have we not had enough of this Brave New World?

I do, and so does the author, but clearly you are either missing the point or you have not had enough yet.

Re:Google Has a Striking History of Bias Against Black Girls by politician on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @04:05PM (#16701408)
You're right! I reread the article, and the author aligns ideologically with most of the commenters in this thread, including myself.
Re:Google Has a Striking History of Bias Against Black Girls by maxerickson on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @03:56PM (#16701304)
I think they are already engaged in the business of trying to provide high quality, personalized results.

Is it your argument that they should be prevented from doing this because highly personalized, low quality results might instead be the result of their efforts?

Re:Google Has a Striking History of Bias Against Black Girls by doorbumper on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @03:35PM (#16701084)
If Google's human inputs have racial bias that is certainly something that should be fixed. DuckDuckGo has safe search on by default.

> That a query for an innocent term such as 'black girls' even with 'safe search off' should not result in a bunch of porn.

I don't know what results the search term 'black girls' should return. If you just search for it, it doesn't return any porn for me. If you're seeing porn, your search results make reflect your search history since Google will customize your results based on your search history. Interesting.

That being said, it should return whatever people are searching for. We must be careful not to cross the line from fixing mistakes to politically correct moral censorship.

Re:Google Has a Striking History of Bias Against Black Girls by jacquesm on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @03:39PM (#16701124)
On Google I get the same results as the writer of the article for 'black girls', on Bing I get a bunch of porn. So it looks as if Google has permanently adjusted the results for this particular query.
Re:Google Has a Striking History of Bias Against Black Girls by politician on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @03:42PM (#16701156)
I think it's possible we're actually in violent agreement due, in part, to our different result set from Google. Even "incognito mode" doesn't return for me the set of salacious results reported by the author.
Re:Google Has a Striking History of Bias Against Black Girls by jacquesm on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @03:48PM (#16701213)
She clearly states this is what happened in 2009.
Re:Google Has a Striking History of Bias Against Black Girls by politician on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @04:01PM (#16701360)
You're right! The screenshot of the naughty results was taken in 2011, and the revised results in 2016.