I definitely think that mining cryptocurrency on other people's machines without their consent is malicious, and I am glad that the security industry is treating this as an exploit. This shares similarities with ads in webpages, which run without my consent.
However, unlike ads, mining scripts don't grab my attention without my consent, they only use my processing power, which is something I would be willing to negotiate for the right website. I'd be happy to click a button which says "Allow nytimes.com to mine cryptocurrency on your browser while you browse their website", for example. There would need to be secure systems in place around this sort of mechanism--I'd rather have this implemented by the browser than as a JS script--but this might provide an alternative to pay models which sites seem unwilling to try, and ad models which I am unwilling to agree to.
The users of the platform are not the people who include Coinhive on hacked websites. Pr0gramm simply allowed its users to voluntarily mine in their browsers and be rewarded with a premium account. The main benefit of a premium account is, that no ads are shown on the site.
They're apparently basement dwellers. Hint: basement dwellers don't pay their own electricity bill.
Ya know, I wonder if poeple hat agree to this have made comments online about global warming and how serious a threat it is, and how dirty deniers are stupidbadpeople?
Because being proCrypto in my mind, is just like that same type of hippy type being anti-nuclear, just with more irony and ignorance.
And I’m not someone that believes 1/2 the gloom and doom, just that I like the hypocrisy of “climate informed” types being pro-crypto which is the biggest waste of power we’ve ever made.
I don't know any particulars of this specific situation, but I would caution folks against accepting this sort of claim at face value. The GamerGate "movement" sprinkled donations to charity in with telling women that they wanted to rape and kill them. There are gradations here.
I think this is just an assertion without evidence.
The point which Pr0gramm users are making is that the Pr0gramm users donating to cancer research and the Pr0gramm users mining through Coinhive might be different people, and lumping them together because they all use Pr0gramm would be unfair (this is the argument they're making--I don't know whether it's true).
Before Coinhive was launched, users on Pr0gramm were able to activate mining and be rewarded with a premium account on the site. They weren't even forced to do so but were able to opt-in voluntarily.
So the relation between Coinhive and Pr0gramm merely is, that the people behind each website know each other and used Pr0gramm as a testbed for Coinhive before it became publicly available.
I think you misunderstood something. Pr0gramm users can use something like coinhive voluntarily, on their own machine only, unless they like blasting their login data out into the internet. This can be used to get premium time for this pr0gramm account and nothing else.
The connection here is, that this was the prototype for what is now coinhive, which has been developed by the former pr0gramm admin.
This is the connection between pr0gramm and coinhive. I don't think anyone ever claimed (not even Krebs) a lot of pr0gramm users would be involved in blackhat usage of coinhive. It's an imageboard with thousands of users. I mean, seriously, the amout of people on HN proportionally that use coinhive in a blackhat way is probably higher than on pr0gramm. Simply because most people here have the technical skill to do it, where pr0gramm is simply a website for shitposting.
At the surface level, it's an attack on Krebs, but there's a secondary thing going on here.
Krebs' main investigation was on Coinhive, a group which embeds Monero mining scripts in pages which run on page visitors' machines. But in his criticism of Coinhive and its association with Pr0gramm, it seems he may have cast too wide a net, doxxing and accusing Pr0gramm users who may not have anything to do with Coinhive. Instead of apologizing for this, he doubled down on it, typifying Pr0gramm users as basement dwellers who anonymously post nastygrams and threaten journalists with death.
Donating to cancer research is a direct response to that: it shows that Pr0gramm users are at least not only bad--they also do things generally considered altruistic, like donating to cancer research.
Both sides have definitely dirtied their hands: at least some Pr0gramm users are mining cryptocurrency on other people's machines through Coinhive, and Krebs has definitely made the false insinuation that Monero's anonymity is only useful for criminal activity. The open question is whether this behavior is typical of Pr0gramm or Krebs has actually accused Pr0gramm users who weren't involved in Coinhive.
I don't know who is in the right here--I simply don't have enough information to know. What information I do have comes from sources which are clearly biased. But it's interesting to see how even at this level, security cases are being tried in the court of public opinion.