Re:Uber will not re-apply for self-driving car permit in Cal...
by jrkatz on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @11:20AM
(#16698343)
You bring some good information into this, which also gets more to the point I was trying to make, specific math aside - though I am comforted your math shows my flights are probably safer! Given that neither airplane journeys & miles nor automobile journeys & miles are created equally, per-mile statistics aren't particularly meaningful to an individual traveler.
Re:Uber will not re-apply for self-driving car permit in Cal...
by Retric on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @10:34AM
(#16697953)
First those 2600 miles are not absolutely safe, so it is a higher risk than an average trip.
And if you qualify the airline deaths based on journey type then you also need to qualify the car trip by journey type. As he is presumably sober, not tired, using a seat belt, not speeding 30+ MPH over speed limit etc his risks of dying over 10 miles is less than half that of the average 10 miles driven.
So, his risk of death per trip is actually higher when flying.
[1]: https://www.statisticbrain.com/airplane-crash-statistics/
The same page gives the odds of dying in a single airplane flight as 1 in 29.4 million. The odds of dying per mile driven are approximately 1 in 174 million. On that basis, your 10 mile journey has a risk of death of approximately 1 in 17.4 million - death is 1.7x more likely.
There's probably a bunch of other ways to interpret the statistics - car miles aren't created equally either, there's a difference between long haul and short haul flight fatality statistics, there's a big difference based on where the airline operates. It's (like all things in life) not very clear cut.