Re:Avoid Else, Return Early (2013)
by klmr on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @10:57AM
(#16689037)
> middle code has no idea that there's this new exception and leaks resources
You misunderstand how `finally` works. The whole point is that it runs regardless of exception type. So the resulting code in the middle layer doesn’t need to know anything about the code it calls, and doesn’t leak resources, even when calling or called code changes: It’s not brittle.
> or you're wrapping pretty much all function bodies with try-catch-finally-rethrow.
No need for `catch` and rethrowing. And in the case of C# and modern Java, no need for the rest either: You only need to wrap resources that you allocate into `using` (C#) or `try` (Java; but not `try…finally`! [1]). Sure, it’s more verbose than RAII in other languages with automatic storage duration (like C++). But it effectively performs the same.
You misunderstand how `finally` works. The whole point is that it runs regardless of exception type. So the resulting code in the middle layer doesn’t need to know anything about the code it calls, and doesn’t leak resources, even when calling or called code changes: It’s not brittle.
> or you're wrapping pretty much all function bodies with try-catch-finally-rethrow.
No need for `catch` and rethrowing. And in the case of C# and modern Java, no need for the rest either: You only need to wrap resources that you allocate into `using` (C#) or `try` (Java; but not `try…finally`! [1]). Sure, it’s more verbose than RAII in other languages with automatic storage duration (like C++). But it effectively performs the same.
[1] https://docs.oracle.com/javase/tutorial/essential/exceptions...