Re:'The Gig Economy' Is the New Term for Serfdom
by grasshopperpurp on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @10:24AM
(#16688666)
Well, which parts do you disagree with? Or, do you just disagree with the sensationalist language?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:'The Gig Economy' Is the New Term for Serfdom
by reading-at-work on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @11:10AM
(#16689218)
I agree that humans in general with unchecked power can become dictatorial maniacs. I disagree that the CEOs of ride-hailing companies specifically will become dictatorial maniacs. I think that kind of sensationalist language discredits the article to a large degree, and doesn't contribute to the author's argument in a concrete way. It's an appeal to emotion, not a rational and defensible argument.
Re:'The Gig Economy' Is the New Term for Serfdom
by grasshopperpurp on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @11:54AM
(#16689695)
Appreciate you breaking that down, and I agree that the sensationalist language is not helpful (preaching to the choir, etc.), but I think discredits goes too far. I can say something completely true in the most obnoxious way possible, and it can turn off a lot of people, but it doesn't alter the truth.
I believe that he's harping on CEOs of ride-hailing companies, because they're the obvious example that everyone is familiar with. His overall statement, as I read it, is closer to:
>humans in general with unchecked power can become dictatorial maniacs.
And, I think that's the salient point. Others have hit on it, but if a society is too Capitalistic or too Socialistic, the power-hungry people (who always have and, presumably, always will exist) will take advantage of the imbalance, and the people (general population) will suffer as a result. On a large scale, it shouldn't matter how evil/greedy any CEO or politician is, because their power should be limited. The problem, of course, is finding the right balance.