News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on Thinking Differently about Thinking: The Mind-Expanding Ideas of Andy Clark. Parent comment

Re:Thinking Differently about Thinking: The Mind-Expanding I... by truculation on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @09:40AM (#16688196)
The way I see it is that my identity is a set of fallible memories which are stored in my brain. If I write some of those memories down in a notebook, journal or diary, have I extended my mind?

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't see how. If I write about the first house I grew up in, and then forget all about it, can that old notebook recognise the extant building? If I hold the closed notebook in my hand, waft it around a bit, will we recognise the house? For recognition to happen there has to be some matching or prediction of sensory data by memory data. All of which takes place in a fairly small volume and time window, within the brain. Extended body, yes. Extended memory, yes. 'Extended mind', not so much. Not yet.

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Thinking Differently about Thinking: The Mind-Expanding I... by AgentME on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @02:22PM (#16691316)
If I disconnect and remove the part of my brain that holds my memory of my house, and walk in front of my house while holding that part of my brain in my hand as lumpy inert matter that's not understood/wired to the rest of me, we won't recognize the house either.

A notebook is swap space that has to be causally linked to you somehow (through your eyes, etc) to be useful just like a part of your brain has to be linked to you (generally through direct wiring).

[ Parent | on HN ]