Re:Uber disabled Volvo SUV's safety system before fatality
by tzakrajs on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @11:18AM
(#16689302)
The self driving should be capable of mitigating this risk by adapting to systems like these in general.
Re:Uber disabled Volvo SUV's safety system before fatality
by fixermark on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @11:31AM
(#16689457)
Problem is, that greatly complicates the problem-solviing process for SD vehicles---you're now trying to build atop a model of the world provided by the vendor, with its own faults and quirks (and you probably need an agreement with the vendor to see their code / dissect their model, and now your release schedule depends on their release schedule, etc.). It also makes Uber dependent upon Volvo's buy-in on the project, and that arrangement is fraught in a world where we don't yet know if SD cars are going to damage the business of traditional auto manufacturers 50 years out---Uber wants to be in a place where if a vendor relationship sours, they can pack up and change chassis without a complete overhaul of the SD logic.
If your SD system is supposed to be solving 100% of the same problem anyway, it's best to gut the software you don't control and work with the hardware as directly as you can. The notion of building atop a lower-level abstraction makes for great academia but doesn't work with industrial realities.
Re:Uber disabled Volvo SUV's safety system before fatality
by tzakrajs on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @12:00PM
(#16689764)
Thanks for the explanation and I agree that it won't be as easy to build SD for auto braking systems that change from chassis to chassis, but this is what I think people want. People want to have fail safes from different vendors.
There are plenty of intentional maneuvers required to integrate with real-world (ie. non perfect) traffic that trigger these systems.
They’re designed to take hints from human input (so for example, LKA responds less strongly to forceful unexpected inputs than a lack of expected input).
There is 0 chance the system wouldn’t interfere with a self driving.
Not to mention many of those safety systems include lockouts on the CAN bus which make removing their safety module a first step to even add your own inputs. I know that’s how it works on my Volt with a Mobileye sensor