Aerospace engineer here. Different systems controlling the same end-points is literally a basic engineering safety technique. Not only you have the human pilot as a competing system controlling the same end-points as the autopilot, you may have even different competing autopilots.
I had a professor at the Uni who was part of the engineering team of the flight computer of a certain jet fighter. Two engineering teams were given the specs of the system and told to produce a flight computer. The two teams weren't allowed to talk to each other to prevent bugs cross-pollinating the two systems. After all, what good is to have two identical system for redundancy if they can be affected by the same bug? (That's also why pilots eat different meals in-flight!)
Then, the two completely different systems are installed, duplicated, into the plane and put to the test. The four computers must perform equally as per the specs. If the recommended output of a single computer diverges from the other three, that computer is faulty and disregarded. If two computers of the same design have a bug and start giving out-of-envelope readings but the other two are consistent, control is handled to them.
I'm certainly very appalled to see in this thread how safety engineering techniques that every engineer learns in University is completely disregarded or even reversed. At least in the aerospace community, development and implementation of these safety techniques has been paid in blood. These are lessons that shouldn't be forgotten when developing other transport technologies IMHO.
Aerospace (and medical) is where things are much better.
In a modern car there are plenty of systems that independently will start. An example is some cars that are fixed to prepare your breaks if you take your foot off the accelerator quickly, more or less giving you instant breaking. At the same time, completely independent of this, emergency breaking might already have been started by the collision detection system.
This way there won't be 2 breaking systems competing with one-another. Different systems controlling the same end-points is never a good idea.