News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook–while it apologizes for scandal–funds campaign t... by vijaybritto on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @02:04AM (#16685701)
Yes, they should do their jobs without any extra nudging I suppose?
Re:Facebook–while it apologizes for scandal–funds campaign t... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @02:11AM (#16685744)
> they should do their jobs without any extra nudging I suppose?

Consider a U.S. Senator representing Arkansas considering a bill regulating nuclear energy. The Senator is no expert in nukes. How should he determine to whom to speak? If a renowned nuclear physicist in California wants to speak with the Senator, should that be banned?

Lobbying, i.e. people--individually or in assembly--expressing their political views to elected leaders, is an inherent side effect of the First Amendment. (And, I'd argue, of democracy.)

Re:Facebook–while it apologizes for scandal–funds campaign t... by vijaybritto on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @02:23AM (#16685792)
But there are well-functioning Democracies in Europe without any sort of lobbying right? Bringing in money automatically removes a ton of people right? The people needing reforms most are the poor and the money makes it impossible for them to have a voice!
Re:Facebook–while it apologizes for scandal–funds campaign t... by sosborn on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @03:19AM (#16686081)
It might not be called lobbying, but I assure you equivalents exist. The thing is that most people think that lobbying = bribery. It simply isn’t true.

The process can be corrupted, but that is true regardless of the vehicle.

Re:Facebook–while it apologizes for scandal–funds campaign t... by wvenable on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @02:20AM (#16685782)
Why is money involved, though?
Re:Facebook–while it apologizes for scandal–funds campaign t... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @02:29AM (#16685820)
> Why is money involved, though?

Two factors over which we don't have a national consensus.

One: the line between political and non-political speech is tough to draw. If I write a blog about the minimum wage, is that political? What if I do it full time? Now I hire a copy editor--is that political spending? What if the blog is openly--and intentionally--partisan?

Two: a metric to determine the degree to which money is a factor in a given piece of speech. Say I paint a political mural on my house's public-facing wall. Is the paint political spending? What if I hire someone to paint it for me, but based on my design? What if my neighbor lets me paint her house? What if my other neighbor, to whom I give the oranges from my orange tree every year, lets me do the same? What if I commission the art but paint it myself?