News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Should I ignore a cease and desist letter from ou... by cperciva on Tuesday September 07, 2010 @01:55AM (#1668209)
If you access their servers without their permission and without accepting their terms of service, you put yourself at risk of a lawsuit or possibly even criminal charges depending on how zealous your local prosecutors are (so far the question of whether TOS violations can constitute criminal unauthorized access to computer systems is an open question legally). This is particularly true if they take technical measures, such as banning IP addresses, in an attempt to keep you out and you circumvent those measures -- to make an offline analogy, it's much easier to prove a case of trespassing if said trespass involved climbing over a 15' fence.

If you merely provide a tool which your customers use, things are much less problematic. The only way I could see this causing difficulties would be if they claimed that they owned the copyright on their users' data, but it seems to me that it would be very difficult to make such an argument stand up.

So my non-lawyerly input is that if you should definitely not access their servers directly, but providing code to allow your customers to access their own data is probably fine.

Re:Ask HN: Should I ignore a cease and desist letter from ou... by cullenking on Tuesday September 07, 2010 @03:14AM (#1668326)
That was my assumption. They never took any technical measures to prevent us from doing it, they just sent us a letter. Calling it a cease and desist is a bit generous, as it wasn't crafted very well, or by a lawyer.

I am not worried about arguing over copyright, considering that ultimately, if the user created the map using Google's maps, then Google trumps all. If it was created by uploading a log file, then it's more gray, but, the user provided a file created by hardware they own, and MMR is merely representing it on a map. I can't imagine they can successfully pursue a copyright case.

Thanks for the input!