News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency by tomrod on Monday March 26, 2018 @03:50PM (#16681895)
> I'm not sure what you would like as proof

As mentioned in my prior comment:

>> Show me the proof, the diff-in-diff, the actual assessment of incrementality generalizable to the channel for established companies. Otherwise there are competing theories which equally explain the effectiveness or lack thereof of the digital advertising channel, such as FOMO/prisoner's dilemma.

From your comment, you agree with FOMO/prisoner's dilemma even if you don't agree with the context of the jargon. As you mention, signaling theory is a more proper term for what we are describing, but signaling is efficient if we get to a separating equilibrium (e.g. quality differentiation of product) which clearly we don't see. Ergo FOMO/prisoner's dilemma is likely a better fitting model (though with some admittedly post hoc bias).

So the proof I am asking for is not existence of digital marketing spend, because that isn't proof of effectiveness of digital impact at all and has competing theories sufficient to cast shade on it as full explanation, but incremental improvement over other existing channels (and for established companies, doing nothing at all).

Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency by manigandham on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @02:47PM (#16691555)
It either works or it doesn't, and you seem to agree that it does, so you're asking how it's better than existing channels? That's completely up to implementation and 1000s of factors as mentioned, and it doesn't need to be better than any other model to be useful for the bottomline, only that it returns a positive ROAS (return on ad spend).

A company selling to younger people might only advertise online while another only sells well through TV commercials. I don't see how that tells you anything useful other than to use the right media mix for your marketing needs.

That being said, whether a medium works is very easily proven by changing spend in isolation and seeing the impact on sales, and it's done by every major company. If spend exists, then campaigns exist, and so a outcome on sales can be measured as compared to the lack of spend (and thus campaigns). I'm unsure sure why that isn't evidence for you.