News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Being frugal is for the rich by throwaway84742 on Monday March 26, 2018 @03:40PM (#16681797)
Most young people do need to be more thoughtful about their money, though. And the economy as a whole is, by multiple different metrics, the best it’s ever been. It’s just that this greatness needs to be spread a bit wider. In the capitalist system with a labor market as tight as we’ve ever seen it this is addressed by getting another job for more money. Now is a good time to do it. You are responsible for your own success.
Re:Being frugal is for the rich by danudey on Monday March 26, 2018 @04:13PM (#16682109)
The economy is the best its ever been, but wealth inequality is the worst its ever been. The cost of living has gone up far, far faster than income has, while wages have stagnated or dropped, meaning people these days are earning less money and have more expenses than before.

To hear someone who was making $10/hour out of college and bought a home for $40,000 say that the reason millennials can't buy a home today is because they're buying avocado toast and not because equivalent homes cost $1.6 million today is infuriating. Relatively speaking, millennials are doing better, frugally, than baby boomers were (saving more, spending less, etc), but the cost of the things that people are complaining about has grown exponentially.

Meanwhile, almost all of the growth of the economy has gone towards the top 1% of people. If you look at, for example, Canada, the average CEO makes as much by January 2nd as the average worker does by December 31st.

CEO pay growth over the last few decades has skyrocketed (compared to inflation, worker wages, or even corporate profits), while worker wages basically track inflation. In other words, people are making the same amount of money as people 50 years ago, even though a lot of things cost more (e.g. housing).

Blaming the economy inequality on the fact that people aren't willing to take on second jobs ignores the fact that wealth and power is all being concentrated in a small number of people and the rest of us are forced to fight over what they're willing to leave behind for everyone else.

Re:Being frugal is for the rich by Consultant32452 on Monday March 26, 2018 @04:48PM (#16682449)
Do you actually care about the well-being of the poor, or do you just hate the rich? Because you seem much more concerned about the relative difference between the rich and the poor than you do about the nominal well-being of anyone. Population densities have increased and it's more expensive to live in cities. That's for sure. We opened up free trade which gave the American middle class a minor kick in the pants at the expense of bringing huge swaths of India and China up to a position of basic food security, increased healthcare, education, and just about every other measurement of well-being you can think of.

Your essential argument is that from a relative perspective the American middle class is not as well off as it was during a unique time following WWII during which the American middle class reached the highest levels of relative wealth in the history of the planet. Okay, but they're still nominally better off than they were back then and an almost unimaginable number of people have had their lives dramatically improved across the globe in the process.

Re:Being frugal is for the rich by Frondo on Monday March 26, 2018 @05:12PM (#16682639)
No one's talking about hating the rich here but you.

We can all care about societal inequality, and how it probably suggests that the levers of civilization need to be jiggered a bit, without hating anyone.

I think housing in the PNW is way unaffordable but that doesn't mean I hate either the developers, the planners, or the numerous other social and geographical factors that have led to this situation.

In short, please don't bring up things like "hate the rich" when no one else is.

Re:Being frugal is for the rich by Consultant32452 on Monday March 26, 2018 @05:59PM (#16683033)
Your primary complaint could have all the wind taken out of its sails if we just magically took all the money away from wealthy people and burned it. Because wealth inequality would go down. It wouldn't actually help anyone, but wealth inequality would go down.

Affordable housing is a problem best addressed by the people who live in the areas that have a lack of affordable housing. It's not something that needs addressing on the national scale.

Re:Being frugal is for the rich by your-nanny on Monday March 26, 2018 @07:23PM (#16683646)
It might help, actually. Your assumption is that what the rich do with their mmonet doesn't actually hurt the poor; but it can. Itcab be used to purchase narratives and political influence in ways deeply harmful
Re:Being frugal is for the rich by Consultant32452 on Monday March 26, 2018 @08:22PM (#16684024)
You're still focusing your attention on supposed bad behavior of the rich rather than the wellbeing of the poor.

If you think the poor need something, like say more funding for inner city schools, then say that and suggest a reasonable tax, perhaps a tax on luxury goods that would disproportionately affect the wealthy. Or if there's a specific bad behavior, such as pharmaceutical advertising, talk about that. But just complaining about wealth inequality sounds more like hating the rich than caring about the poor.

Re:Being frugal is for the rich by Frondo on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @06:04PM (#16702435)
You're free not to care about inequality, so go for it.

I haven't seen any convincing evidence-based argument that a high degree of inequality is either neutral or good for society as a whole, nor do I have any philosophical leanings that suggest that it is an acceptable byproduct of an otherwise fair and just society.

Going by both evidence (health outcomes, class mobility, etc) and by my philosophical leanings that it don't seem right for so few people to own so much (when ownership itself is a purely fictional thing), I'm going to keep talking about inequality as a Bad Thing to be addressed.

Don't like it? You do you, but telling me I'm focusing my behavior on one thing or another is about the least compelling thing to say.

Re:Being frugal is for the rich by your-nanny on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @06:37AM (#16686994)
But rich people largely advocate against policies that favor poor people, like generous welfare and equitable taxation. Rich people advocate for policies that protect their status and the value of their properties and investments. They advocate against redistributive inheritance taxes, so that their own children continue to have enormous advantages over anyone else. They advocate policies that guarantee they can continue to extract wealth from rents rather than productive avtivities, dragging down the economic well being of all. And the rich are more likely to cheat on their taxes, try to bribe officials, or flat out disregard the law. And the rich have disproportionate power to do so, and work very hard to make it stay that way.
Re:Being frugal is for the rich by Consultant32452 on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @10:45AM (#16688906)
>But rich people largely advocate against policies that favor poor people, like generous welfare and equitable taxation. Rich people advocate for policies that protect their status and the value of their properties and investments.

Do you suppose it's possible for you to advocate for a specific amount of welfare that you feel is "generous" without attempting to villainize the very people you hope to pay for it?

>They advocate against redistributive inheritance taxes, so that their own children continue to have enormous advantages over anyone else.

First, one of the major motivations of achieving success in life is so that your children will be better off. So all you've established is that rich people are good parents. Secondly, you're still just upset that someone has a lot, rather than focusing on a specific problem that some group of poor people has. You're just hating the rich rather than showing an interest in helping the poor. Third, fortunes generally disappear after 3 generations, so it's not as if huge dynasties are being created that last forever. If you're rich, your grandkids get to go to a nice private school. That's pretty much it.

>They advocate policies that guarantee they can continue to extract wealth from rents rather than productive avtivities, dragging down the economic well being of all.

Yes, things like regulatory capture are a problem. I will hold up a sign and protest it alongside you. But do you see you you're STILL pointing to the "rich" rather than "bad policy?"

>And the rich are more likely to cheat on their taxes, try to bribe officials, or flat out disregard the law.

I've never met a person who worked for tips that didn't cheat on their taxes, have you? But more importantly, we're back at the same place. Rather than advocating for or against a specific policy, you're just slinging mud. You care more about saying mean things about rich people than you do about issues the poor might be facing.

Re:Being frugal is for the rich by your-nanny on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @05:49PM (#16693057)
Your saying that I do doesn't make it so. You should read more carefully. Look at is absolutely as simple as this: the interests of the rich and the nonrich are systematically at odds, yet only one of these groups have any great power to see to it that their interests are served. A society so structured is unjust, fragile, and generally suboptimal. Such societies lend themselves to demogougery and collapse. One needbt even resort to claims of moral and ethical failure on the part of those who have power to conclude this thing, and yet it is also true that power and wealth have deletrious effects on a number of features of that which we might call virtue, including empathy.
Re:Being frugal is for the rich by Consultant32452 on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @06:19PM (#16693309)
>the interests of the rich and the nonrich are systematically at odds

This is not universally true. It is not true across individuals among the rich/nonrich nor is it true across specific agenda items. This caricature you've created for these two groups is called classism. You are no better than the people who think all poor people are stupid or lazy.

>yet only one of these groups have any great power to see to it that their interests are served.

Okay, let's talk about campaign finance reform. Or is making sure there's no rich people more important to you than making sure everyone has equal political power?

Re:Being frugal is for the rich by your-nanny on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @07:13PM (#16693684)
Systematically does not mean universally. It means, at a minimum, that their interests diverge non randomly.

Saying that rich and nonrich have different interests is not controversial, except to those intent on denying what is obviously true.

Either you are ill equipped to engage in a discussion on this topic or you are being utterly disingenuous; certainly you have misrepresented what I have said in ways that push a rather tired narrative, one trotted out every time someone pushes back on the status quo of enormous wealth disparity by noting that it has serious negative consequences.

Re:Being frugal is for the rich by squeegee5 on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @01:58PM (#16700105)
Your class warfare demagoguery is entertaining. The entirety of notable human civilization is defined by exploitation, and nobody who matters will ever care. Except politicians who will use your whining and vote to do whatever they were planning to do anyways. Vast inequality is, and always has been, the mark of a great civilization.
Re:Being frugal is for the rich by Consultant32452 on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @09:51PM (#16694544)
>one trotted out every time someone pushes back on the status quo of enormous wealth disparity by noting that it has serious negative consequences.

You just can't help yourself. Once again you express more hatred for the rich than you do concern for the wellbeing of the poor.

I'm not denying that there are consequences to wealth or income disparity. I just think you don't appear to care about the wellbeing of the poor beyond the minimal lip-service you have to pay it to justify voicing your hatred for the rich.

Re:Being frugal is for the rich by your-nanny on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @06:42AM (#16687019)
Sometimes wealth is the problem.
Re:Being frugal is for the rich by sokoloff on Monday March 26, 2018 @05:33PM (#16682828)
> The cost of living has gone up far, far faster than income has, while wages have stagnated or dropped, meaning people these days are earning less money and have more expenses than before.

Common talking point, not borne out by data.

See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16682711 for references.

Re:Being frugal is for the rich by throwaway84742 on Monday March 26, 2018 @04:21PM (#16682178)
Demand more money. You’re now in a position to do so.
Re:Being frugal is for the rich by bsder on Monday March 26, 2018 @03:58PM (#16681968)
> In the capitalist system with a labor market as tight as we’ve ever seen it this is addressed by getting another job for more money.

Is it tight?

I see very few occupations with rising wages. That's the REAL test for a tight labor market.

Let me be anecdotal for a moment ...

I was at a conference recently where the companies had a panel session complaining about getting more people into the business. Unlike most software disciplines, they really do have an infeed problem. In addition, they are also getting poached and losing their junior guys from the shop floor.

Okay, think I, I was a hiring manager in the DotCom Boom(tm), I understand getting poached in a narrow field.

So, do you know who their primary opponents are?

Amazon and Foxconn.

Two of the worst employers on the planet. You are losing employees from your manufacturing line to Amazon warehousing and Foxconn manufacturing.

Um, please go bankrupt and may your industry die in a fire if you treat people so badly as to lose them to Amazon and Foxconn.

Re:Being frugal is for the rich by throwaway84742 on Monday March 26, 2018 @04:16PM (#16682140)
Wages are rising at the highest rate since 2009: https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/02/02/582641530....

And black unemployment is at historic lows a well.

Re:Being frugal is for the rich by AstralStorm on Monday March 26, 2018 @04:32PM (#16682295)
Rates do not matter unless they are over big time scales. You have conveniently picked a year just past the banking crisis...

Does the absolute inflation and purchasing power adjusted value even match 90s?

Re:Being frugal is for the rich by sokoloff on Monday March 26, 2018 @05:36PM (#16682842)
> Does the absolute inflation and purchasing power adjusted value even match 90s?

Yes: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16682711 for references. (Wages rising slightly faster than inflation over decades long period.)

Re:Being frugal is for the rich by throwaway84742 on Monday March 26, 2018 @04:58PM (#16682538)
Sounds to me like you’ve already made up your mind if “rates do not matter”. Because objectively they do.
Re:Being frugal is for the rich by AnimalMuppet on Monday March 26, 2018 @05:16PM (#16682674)
AstralStorm's point is somewhat divergent from the thread of the conversation. It is that, for playing "catch-up" to years of wage stagnation, this month's wage growth rate doesn't mean much. We need years of high wage growth, not just one month or even one year. In this sense, AstralStorm is right that instantaneous rates do not in fact matter. And you sound like you're going to just label everyone who disagrees with you as having their mind already made up, rather than actually thinking about what they say.

That said, the original discussion was about the rate of wage growth as a measure of how tight the labor market is. In that sense, the instantaneous rate is fine.

So why am I harassing you about your answer to AstralStorm, when AstralStorm was disagreeing based on something that was outside the scope of the discussion at hand? Because of the way you answered, with dismissiveness rather than actually thinking about the point raised. That's not cool.

Re:Being frugal is for the rich by s73v3r_ on Monday March 26, 2018 @06:30PM (#16683246)
That's not a meaningful stat, considering 2009 was the onset of the Great Recession. Wages are still not great.
Re:Being frugal is for the rich by CocaKoala on Monday March 26, 2018 @04:37PM (#16682350)
"The economy is doing great, all you need to do to flourish is work a second job in addition to your first one!"
Re:Being frugal is for the rich by throwaway84742 on Monday March 26, 2018 @04:57PM (#16682525)
I didn’t say a “second” job. I suggested to merely change the one people have right now. In my experience this is by far the surest way to increase one’s compensation. Do this once every 2 years, it adds up.