gitk 7-8 years ago, Github desktop app few years later. I used version control features in Eclipse and IntelliJ for SVN, but I believe the same interface maps to Git as well.
None of them even compare with Magit. They offer a small subset of Git features - unlike Magit, which gives you almost all of them, + some higher level abstractions (like "merge into"), and you're always one ! ! press away from entering a manual command. Also, the other interfaces I've used were mostly mouse based, whereas Magit just flows. Feels order of magnitude more efficient than anything else.
> you're always one ! ! press away from entering a manual command
Huh, I didn't know this. I'll probably live in Magit from now on.
Also useful: any time you find yourself wondering what did Magit just do, press $ to display raw output from git commands (lists the commands issued and their return codes, TAB expands them to full output).
I don't do it that often but I felt compelled to tip magit maintainer because it's just a beautiful and important piece of my emacs life.
Magit had a Kickstarter recently (yes, an Emacs mode on Kickstarter; I was shocked too), to raise funds for continued development. I dropped some cash there; after all, it helps me quite a lot to earn my paycheck.
is it because Kickstarter is contradictory to FSF mindset ?
I couldn't pay on KS so I asked him his paypal handle, but it was the KS campaign that motivated me. As you said, it's a great asset to the day of developpers (or any document maintainer under git)
I wonder if there's one that is as good as magit (my opinion is no, but that's why I ask)