News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency by wpietri on Sunday March 25, 2018 @05:03PM (#16674592)
It is definitely not true for news and book publishing.

For news, consider things like the Chinese wall [1] between news and ad sales, the formal ad standards that news organizations will have, and the fact that at least traditionally, humans manually sell those ads, resulting in oversight.

For books, I'm not even sure what you mean. Book publishers sell books that they think will do well and, mostly, that reflect well on them. You can't just walk into Random House with a credit card and say, "Here's my manuscript, please put it in book stores nationwide."

Personally, I'd just ban all advertising. The economic-theory reason we need it, purchasers discovering better ways to solve their needs, has been made mostly unnecessary by the Internet. Now if you want to buy a foo you just search for "foo reviews" and you're off to the races. We'd figure out other ways to fund things.

As an aside, that justification was always a little... generous. Coca Cola doesn't spend billions per year on ads because they're just trying to reach people who've never heard of their products. They do it because they want to manipulate people into buying Coke. I say we can trust people to find unhealthy addictions all on their own.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_wall#Journalism

Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency by wutbrodo on Sunday March 25, 2018 @05:48PM (#16674815)
> For news, consider things like the Chinese wall [1] between news and ad sales

Literally the second line of the two lines of the linked section talks about the (increasingly common) cases of it being breached, a natural consequence of increasing ad-blocker usage. Also, everything in the example you're giving relies on old distribution methods, not "news". There's no longer a line between news and "random website who publishes information about events", and I'm not sure how anyone who hasn't been living under a rock for the last 15 years could be naive enough to think otherwise. For God's sake, Buzzfeed was a Pulitzer Prize finalist a year or two ago!

> For books, I'm not even sure what you mean. Book publishers sell books that they think will do well and, mostly, that reflect well on them. You can't just walk into Random House with a credit card and say, "Here's my manuscript, please put it in book stores nationwide."

Amazon is the largest bookseller in the country IINM, and you can very much give them a credit card and start selling your books nationwide. Again, you're confusing increasingly-unpopular (for market reasons) distribution methods with types of media.

The very existence of advertorials is a refutation of the notion that there's any principled way to legally distinguish between advertising and other forms of information, even less so one that wouldn't be riven with loopholes (cf limits on campaign spending and Super PACs' technically-not-for-the-candidates' spending).

> Personally, I'd just ban all advertising.

You seem to be confident that you have a definition of the word advertising that would be robust enough to implement this without enough collateral damage that it wouldn't be trivially unconstitutional. What is your rough proposal for what that definition would be?

FWIW, I generally agree with you that advertising is a collective-action/net-loss problem, but I think you may be falling into the classic trap of "this thing is bad, we should just wish for it to disappear and hold all else equal".

Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency by majewsky on Monday March 26, 2018 @05:18AM (#16677643)
> What is your rough proposal for what [the definition of advertising] would be?

I like the definition of "getting a material benefit from someone for singing their praise". I'm fairly confident this could work with German law (where I live). In the US, it will be more difficult given Citizens United vs. FEC and other such absurdities.

Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency by wpietri on Sunday March 25, 2018 @08:51PM (#16675693)
That the Chinese wall has been sometimes breached is not proof that it doesn't generally still operate. There is definitely a line between real news and random-ass websites. That Buzzfeed is producing some real journalism is definitely not proof that real journalism has stopped existing.

If you think I'm wrong about this, please do go buy an article in one of the top news sites with content of your choosing. And if you can't, then that's a pretty clear sign that it's different than advertising.

That Amazon sells self-published books is definitely not proof that real book publishers just print any old thing. If you think otherwise, again, please demonstrate it. (And that you'd suggest it as equivalent strikes me as either not understanding the point or a desire to be contrary.)

Regarding your constitutional whataboutism, it may be that we would need a constitutional change to fully ban advertising, but I don't think that changes my view that were I king for a day I'd ban all advertising.

Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency by nine_k on Sunday March 25, 2018 @05:34PM (#16674730)
> Here's my manuscript, please put it in book stores nationwide.

I suppose you heard about a company named Amazon. This is basically one of the services they offer for years, if you're OK with selling an e-book.

If your audience prefers dead trees, print-on-demand offers are also numerous.

The problem, as usual, is to make the existence of your book known to potential readers, and this is done by... advertising. And you want it to be targeted unless you enjoy burning money on spamming innocent disinterested people.

Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency by wpietri on Sunday March 25, 2018 @08:52PM (#16675702)
Yes, that is called "self-publishing" because it is distinct from what a real publisher does. Vanity presses have existed for decades at least before Amazon, but they too are irrelevant to the point here.
Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency by bitwize on Monday March 26, 2018 @11:38AM (#16679661)
What a real publisher does is to market and promote your book in addition to just running the presses. Aka advertising. You're just making the GP's point for them.
Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency by wpietri on Saturday March 31, 2018 @01:16AM (#16721871)
A real publisher handles editing, fact-checking, copyediting, layout, cover design, and distribution. As well as marketing, which is distinct from advertising.

Yes, they do also sometimes advertise books, but I don't see how that proves that "anyone with a credit card" can "put out information" of their choosing through a real publisher.

Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency by jasonlotito on Sunday March 25, 2018 @05:40PM (#16674765)
> Personally, I'd just ban all advertising.

That won't happen. The First Amendment would see to that.

Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency by wpietri on Sunday March 25, 2018 @08:57PM (#16675723)
That's not as clear as you suggest. Some advertising restrictions are clearly constitutional (note the lack of cigarette ads, for example), and in the past courts have found that no commercial speech is protected under the constitution. Notably, that includes even the Supreme Court in Valentine v. Chrestensen.

All of which is beside the point, in that my aside was clearly meant as a "if I were in charge" hypothetical. And since it's my hypothetical, I can posit that your puny mortal constitution would not stand up to my hypnobeam powers. So there.

Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency by bitwize on Monday March 26, 2018 @11:46AM (#16679717)
The FCC can regulate or ban certain kinds of advertising on the public airwaves, but a dwindling number of people watch terrestrial OTA television exclusively or predominantly. Private networks (cable, satellite, internet) can set their own rules.
Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency by andrepd on Sunday March 25, 2018 @05:16PM (#16674650)
I think the same way. In the end, advertising creates harm to people. Put aside the numbers, and vacuous phrases like "creating value to the shareholders". The net impact on advertising is harm to people. It's about using tricks, potentially with very harmful side effects, to manipulate people into buying your stuff.

Sometimes I imagine how a world without any type of commercial advertising would be...

Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency by colechristensen on Sunday March 25, 2018 @05:41PM (#16674772)
>It's about using tricks, potentially with very harmful side effects, to manipulate people into buying your stuff.

There is a lot of this, but that is not the whole of advertising. Ads can be informational and useful.

Take the previews at a theater before the feature. Those are ads, they are paid for, and a lot of people like them. If you like movies you'd probably like to know what movies are coming, it's useful for you and useful for the studios. It's a positive sum game.

>Sometimes I imagine how a world without any type of commercial advertising would be...

There would be more of a concentration on other ways to get messaging out. If companies couldn't buy search engine advertisements they would concentrate more on SEO. It's not "advertising" but it has the same effects. There are plenty of side ways into achieving the same propaganda goals.

Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency by wpietri on Monday March 26, 2018 @03:39AM (#16677290)
People could also watch trailers on the Internet without being forced to. In fact, people already do.

If your theory is correct that people want to watch trailers in theaters, then if we ban advertising (that is, the paid placement of content), then they will go on watching them because theaters will show them without being paid to do so. Although they'll likely see fewer misleading trailers for low-quality films, because theaters will no longer have a conflict of interest when deciding what to show.

It's true that companies would spend more on SEO, but that's in effect a fight between search engine companies (who want to find what users want) and other companies (who want to be found whether or not it's what users want). That seems like a fair fight to me.

Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency by chrismcb on Sunday March 25, 2018 @05:51PM (#16674832)
It would be very very very very boring. There would be very little entertainment, at least no professional entertainment. It write all be small amateurish stuff. But you wouldn't know about it, because it couldn't be advertised.
Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency by wpietri on Monday March 26, 2018 @03:33AM (#16677267)
That's just ridiculous. I hear about plenty of professional entertainment even though I very rarely see ads. How? Reviews, bookstore clerks, word of mouth, online recommendations, social media discussion, and event listings.

Entertainment is a big industry because people want to be entertained, not because somebody told them what to watch. They would seek out entertainment in a world without ads. How do I know? Because they already do.

Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency by Moru on Sunday March 25, 2018 @05:36PM (#16674743)
You can't just expect to search for review of a product and get an unbiased review. Companies caught up on that ages ago and pay bloggers money for good reviews. This is how bloggers make money so they can live on their blog after all.