I think it's a false dichotomy.
We use money and investment as a distributed resource allocation system.
It's kind of worked so far, but it is fundamentally flawed and on a catastrophic trajectory.
We've created a self-amplifying dissipative system without any kind of braking system, and we're already wasting the earth away faster than it regenerates.
The growth religion must be dispelled. I hope we can find a system that captures the positive aspects of capitalism while stopping the current destruction/consumption wave.
Why would you say no to them?
Not the most important thing in the world? Sure. Something that millions of people want and are willing to spend 1% of their annual pay check? Yes.
Saying that it makes no sense constitutes a very destructive thinking. When you start thinking of what "makes" or "not makes" sense, you stop being empathetic. There's always a better, "more right", more proper thing to do and millions of people are just wasting their time on something they don't need. But aren't they human beings? Isn't having irrational wants rooted in the humanity itself?
Planned economy was dealing in the same maxims. "People need food". "People need shelter". Also tools and military equipment. Fashion clothes? Nah, screw that, useless. Beauty items? Shenanigans of capitalists. Some variety of food? We don't have resources for that.
We know how that ended up.