News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Omaha man ‘liked’ a tweet, then lost his job by paradite on Saturday March 24, 2018 @02:25AM (#16665174)
Chinese citizen here. A few points that I want to make after reading some comments:

1. I would be personally offended if anyone or any organization lists Tibet as a country.

2. Lots of Chinese people would be offended too by this.

Reasons for 1 and 2:

- It is a piece of wrong information

- The wrong information directly contradicts what is considered basic knowledge in China

- That basic knowledge happens to be on the topic of sovereignty

- Chinese people care a lot of sovereignty (see https://github.com/matomo-org/matomo/issues/6006)

Why do Chinese people care so much about sovereignty? Culture and history.

It is the same question as:

- Why do Americans care so much about freedom of speech, democracy and race equality?

- Why do Japanese people care so much about respect and etiquette?

Now addressing the obvious issue, that some people support the idea of Tibet becoming independent and they should be free to express their ideas. Yes, they are free to say so, but there are two things to keep in mind:

- Opinions are not facts, you can support whatever you want, but don't say it as a fact like "Tibet is a country as of 24 March, 2018." That is not the right thing to do.

- If you choose to freely express your opinions or spread false information, you will face consequences for them. For example, a PR firm would likely tell you that expressing such opinions would results in negative brand image and boycott in China. In addition, saying something like that in China would result in more serious consequences. You might not like it, but that is beyond your control and you should be aware of that.

Re:Omaha man ‘liked’ a tweet, then lost his job by jasonwatkinspdx on Saturday March 24, 2018 @02:34AM (#16665193)
Quite obviously everyone here knows it's not literally about pedantry of whether Tibet is part of China's defacto legal territory.

And none of us care one bit if you're offended.

Your offense to a sense of nationalism, no matter how historical or ingrained, does not excuse the past and continued injustice of what has been forced on the Tibetan people.

Edit: downvotes to this post were literally instantaneous. This topic is most likely being botted.

Re:Omaha man ‘liked’ a tweet, then lost his job by klibertp on Saturday March 24, 2018 @09:27AM (#16666488)
Could you explain what is your view on the acquisition of the Tibetan territory by China?

From what I know about the issue, the transfer of the territory was forced, wasn't it?

What justification do you have for invading and annexation of a previously independent country? Is it that it never was independent in the first place? Do you have any sources to support this?

I come from a country which was occupied in its entirety for over a hundred years - it's arguably worse than what happened to China in the same time-frame. I can understand sovereignty being of prime concern to you. On the other hand, precisely because of a history like that, I can't help but see the Tibetans sovereignty over themselves being denied.

In other words, I'd like to understand: what makes you believe you have a right to take a sovereignty from others as you pursue your own? Is asserting your sovereignty over dead bodies of another nation worth it? (or are Tibetans considered to be 100% Chinese? if so, how come they seem to disagree?)

Re:Omaha man ‘liked’ a tweet, then lost his job by paradite on Saturday March 24, 2018 @10:17AM (#16666686)
I generally disagree with the approach of annexing or colonizing other independent countries. China in particular has suffered much from colonization so that's something we don't like to see happening to other countries.

With that being said, we cannot control what happened in the past, as in the conflicts and sovereignty transfers due to wars that long happened before modern China was born. If you look at the history of China and Tibet, China has exerted sovereignty claims on Tibet since Qing dynasty and Republic of China:

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tibet_under_Qing_rule

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tibet_(1912%E2%80%931951)

And it is the Britain that invaded Tibet during the Chinese rule of Tibet in 1903:

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_expedition_to_Tibet

The reason for the period of de facto independence afterwards is partly due to British invasion leaving a power vacuum and partly due to China busy fighting WW2 and internal civil war between Kuomintang and Communist Party. So I think it is reasonable and legitimate to claim sovereignty properly after WW2 adn the Chinese civil war is over.

Re:Omaha man ‘liked’ a tweet, then lost his job by anonforthis323 on Saturday March 24, 2018 @12:25PM (#16667389)
It's ironic that you are being so severely downvoted in this thread just for stating an honest opinion.
Re:Omaha man ‘liked’ a tweet, then lost his job by sdrothrock on Saturday March 24, 2018 @02:29AM (#16665181)
For an American perspective, I've thought about this a lot while talking to Chinese friends, and I wonder if the closest thing to this in American culture (while not being at all equivalent, just analogous) would be claiming that Puerto Rico is the 51st state.

Factually, it is not.

Emotionally, some people may want it to be and may very well have valid arguments for it.

People across the US and Puerto Rico would have strong opinions on either side of the argument.

Re:Omaha man ‘liked’ a tweet, then lost his job by charlieflowers on Saturday March 24, 2018 @02:36AM (#16665205)
Anecdotally, I'm an American and that statement would get barely a chuckle out of me. I really wouldn't care and most people I know wouldn't either.

So I don't know if it's the best analogy.

Re:Omaha man ‘liked’ a tweet, then lost his job by anonforthis323 on Saturday March 24, 2018 @12:28PM (#16667408)
I think a more appropriate analogy would depend on how the person leans.

It would be like telling a conservative that they stole America from the Natives and should give reparations.

Or it would be like telling a liberal that it was the colonists that made America what it is today, so they don't owe the Natives anything.