Re:C for All
by loup-vaillant on Saturday March 24, 2018 @10:12AM
(#16666664)
> "perform UB, then check whether it happened" doesn't actually work
This raises an interesting point, because in many cases, assuming 2's complement and wrapping around, checking for overflow after the fact, as opposed to preventing it from happening in the first place, is actually easier. (And actually works if you use the `-fwrap` flag.)
The right thing should be easier to do than the wrong thing. It's a shame this is not the case here.
Re:C for All
by loup-vaillant on Saturday March 24, 2018 @07:15AM
(#16666034)
I was of course assuming that `whatever` was positive, and the compiler knew it. See this sibling thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16664546
There are cases where the compiler removes misguided overflow checks, since "perform UB, then check whether it happened" doesn't actually work, but your example is not such a case.