Re:Responsibility Deflected, the CLOUD Act Passes
by tzs on Friday March 23, 2018 @12:05PM
(#16659486)
> London investigators want the private Slack messages of a Londoner they suspect of bank fraud. The London police could go directly to Slack, a U.S. company, to request and collect those messages. The London police would not necessarily need prior judicial review for this request. The London police would not be required to notify U.S. law enforcement about this request. The London police would not need a probable cause warrant for this collection.
Is the implication that before the CLOUD Act, if London police wanted to ask a US company for information they had to notify US law enforcement?
Sure, if they wanted to force a US company to give them information they would have to get the US legal system involved, but as far as I am aware US law enforcement is not a gatekeeper over foreign access to talk to US entities, at least when those foreigners are not from countries that the US restricts contact with in general.
Is the implication that before the CLOUD Act, if London police wanted to ask a US company for information they had to notify US law enforcement?
Sure, if they wanted to force a US company to give them information they would have to get the US legal system involved, but as far as I am aware US law enforcement is not a gatekeeper over foreign access to talk to US entities, at least when those foreigners are not from countries that the US restricts contact with in general.