> For example, Business A has a competitor startup B who has less resources to hire security consultant. Business A hence hired person C to register the service provided by B with a weak password and hire D to breach C's account. C claims that he has been hacked, so he brings startup B to court. B goes bankrupt because it runs out of money to hire lawyers.
You use your knowledge or regulation to read and make decisions. If you don't have the required experience,
> How do I know I have required experience (what experience is required is not said in the regulation text)? I know md5 is insecure and you need salting on password. I'm self learned, garage based entrepreneur with $1000 in my bank to either buy food or hire a consultant, is that required experience?
Right, that's like any other malicious lawsuit – i.e. this is totally irrelevant.
I'm self learned, garage based entrepreneur with $1000 in my bank to either buy food or hire a consultant, is that required experience?
Yes. If you don't have the knowledge or resources to correctly comply with appropriate regulation, then you should not be operating in a space. "I didn't know that I needed to keep raw and cooked meat separate" would not be a valid excuse in food prep; why would "I didn't know I needed to use a secure hash" a valid excuse for an engineer?
For example, the FDA Food Safety and Modernization Act[1] doesn't include specifics about how food should be handled. It specifies some areas where the FDA is supposed to issue rules and then the FDA makes rules based on the authority that the law gives it.
GDPR has Data Protection Offices that issue more specific guidance about how to comply. For instance, the UK Data Protection Office issued this guidance[2] about how to prepare for GDPR.
[1] https://www.fda.gov/NewsEvents/PublicHealthFocus/ucm239907.h...
[2] https://ico.org.uk/media/1624219/preparing-for-the-gdpr-12-s...
There are active, observable, and semi-quantifiable costs to society when lawmakers create arcane, incomprehensible laws meant to prevent entry into markets by making the barrier of compliance too high for most people to afford to compete.
[1] http://money.cnn.com/2016/09/08/news/economy/us-startups-nea...
[2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/on-small-business/wp/201...
Many things might cause low levels of business creation. I am entirely unconvinced that the cost of regulation is one of them.
I wonder if this means we’ll start to see sites/services start out as US only and only become available in Europe once finances are no longer an issue.
It's not. You are wrong.
What if this law will be abused as a tactic to attack business competitions?
Why would that happen?
How do you understand this "security appropriateness" of the above text? How can you be sure your understanding is correct?
You use your knowledge or regulation to read and make decisions. If you don't have the required experience, you hire a consultant or a lawyer. Just like you do when complying with any other piece of legislation.