Re:Avoid getters and setters whenever possible
by acdha on Thursday March 22, 2018 @08:04PM
(#16653890)
> I don't think a User class should be directly validating the zip lives inside the state in some sort of setter method... which one do I set first to make it work? It looks like once I change one I can't change the other any more... I'd need to have a method that changes both at once.
The idea I had in mind for that admittedly contrived example was roughly that you'd have an address class and some logic along the lines of setting a field automatically clears the lower-level fields, but that's not really a practical design as much as an illustration of the pattern of having complex logic in a setter.
I should note that this isn't my preference, either – either set,set,set,validate or updateLotsOfFields(dataStructure) – but I've seen people who felt otherwise and had reasonable arguments for this kind of behaviour.
The idea I had in mind for that admittedly contrived example was roughly that you'd have an address class and some logic along the lines of setting a field automatically clears the lower-level fields, but that's not really a practical design as much as an illustration of the pattern of having complex logic in a setter.
I should note that this isn't my preference, either – either set,set,set,validate or updateLotsOfFields(dataStructure) – but I've seen people who felt otherwise and had reasonable arguments for this kind of behaviour.