News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Power 9 May Dent X86 Servers: Alibaba, Google, Tencent Te... by dragontamer on Thursday March 22, 2018 @04:05PM (#16652204)
Threadripper also only has 8MB of L3 cache per CCX, and you can't hold more than 8MB of data. (true, there are 4x CCX per chip, but you can't "combine" the datasets. You're effectively limited to 8MB per 4-cores. To communicate cross-CCX requires an expensive ping to main-memory) Its a great architecture, but cross-CCX communication is relatively slow and definitely is a concern for some work problems.

Power9 has 120MB of L3 cache that's shared between all cores. Which means you can ACTUALLY have a full 120MB-sized problem set and share all that information between cores.

In short: Threadripper is great for sure, but its not necessarily a fair comparison. In an apples-to-apples comparison (ie: Monero Mining), it seems like a Power9 server is 3x better than Threadripper (Power9 gets ~3000 hash/sec, while Threadripper is roughly 1000 hash/sec).

https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=POWER9-C...

> Using the xmr-stak-power PPC64LE-focused Monero miner, they are seeing great performance with it running on dual pre-production 16-core POWER9 processors. There's a hash rate of 2945H/s while this POWER9 system is pulling 350 Watts DC power.

And mind you: Monero / Cryptonight only uses 2MB of L3 per core. So that's practically Threadripper's ideal problem. Imagine if you actually had a dataset that was larger than the 8MB per CCX that Threadripper is limited to.

Not to hate on Threadripper at all. Its cheap and high performance. I'm seriously considering a Threadripper system myself. But these Power9 specs are incredible, and I'd definitely like to test one if I could afford one.

Re:Power 9 May Dent X86 Servers: Alibaba, Google, Tencent Te... by opencl on Thursday March 22, 2018 @06:50PM (#16653458)
That's a dual socket system with 16 cores per socket. Dual socket Epyc 7351 (also 16 core per socket) is faster and more power efficient than that. 3200H/s at 332W.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=226&v=CS7M392Ia_...

I'm sure there are workloads that really do benefit from the huge unified L3, but it seems like a pretty small niche.

Re:Power 9 May Dent X86 Servers: Alibaba, Google, Tencent Te... by dman on Thursday March 22, 2018 @05:52PM (#16653044)
I really hope AMD releases a 7601 variant that is clocked similarly to the threadripper chips.