News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A... by rayiner on Thursday March 22, 2018 @02:03PM (#16651015)
Except that's not what the bill does. The bill takes an existing law, 18 USC 1591, which provides a narrow scope of liability for "participation in a venture" to perform sex trafficking. I.e. running a sex trafficking business. It redefines "participation in a venture" to include "knowingly ... facilitating" sex trafficking, and then carves out 18 USC 1591 liability from the section 230 safe harbor.

This goes far beyond the backpage situation, which could've been reached with a higher intent standard like "intent to facilitate" sex trafficking.

If Google knows that sex traffickers are using gmail to coordinate their sex-trafficking activities, under the plain text of the statute, they'd be liable for "knowingly facilitating" sex trafficking. This will be abused by prosecutors and plaintiffs' attorneys.

Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A... by sharemywin on Thursday March 22, 2018 @03:16PM (#16651761)
Wouldn't it have to be a specific instance?

Also, What's the definition of know?

Someone somewhere in the organization knew?

you have reasonable processes in place to catch activity?

how does slang, metaphor and euphemism play into it?

Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A... by rayiner on Thursday March 22, 2018 @05:29PM (#16652879)
Yes and no. "Knowing" encompasses "willful blindness," where you have warning signs but deliberately avoid investigating.

If I'm suing Google under the new 18 USC 2421A or the new 18 USC 1595(d), created by this bill, I'm arguing that "Google has tons of warning signs that its services are used by sex traffickers; even if it didn't know about the specific instance of sex trafficking I'm suing over, it was being willfully blind by not having a system in place to identify sex trafficking."

Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A... by davvolun on Thursday March 22, 2018 @04:37PM (#16652476)
I'm really not trying to be facetious,

> If Google knows that sex traffickers are using gmail to coordinate their sex-trafficking activities, they'd be liable for "knowingly facilitating" sex trafficking

Is that not...good? If Google is reading my emails to sell me stuff (and I've given them permission to do so by using their service), and sees (reasonable) evidence I'm engaged in illegal activities, don't they have a responsibility to report that? Is that not the same thing as a GeekSquad technician stumbling across child porn on a laptop they're fixing?

Further, if Google doesn't want to knowingly facilitate, then they shouldn't know -- give me the ability to e2e encrypt my messages and stop reading my emails. Haven't they opened Pandora's box here by going that extra step further and data mining my email?

Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A... by CiPHPerCoder on Thursday March 22, 2018 @05:02PM (#16652670)
> Is that not...good? If Google is reading my emails to sell me stuff (and I've given them permission to do so by using their service), and sees (reasonable) evidence I'm engaged in illegal activities, don't they have a responsibility to report that? Is that not the same thing as a GeekSquad technician stumbling across child porn on a laptop they're fixing?

No, it's not good.

Any internet service provider that reaches mass adoption faces a dilemma:

- Face legal problems

- Become another arm for law enforcement (and maybe even bypass the 4th Amendment)

The prison industrial complex grows fatter.

Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A... by adventured on Thursday March 22, 2018 @10:16PM (#16654563)
The government & corporate prison complex has been declining for about a decade now. It has been rolled back about 20 years. It's not growing fatter:

https://i.imgur.com/ppyHKC4.jpg

By the time pot legalization gets to over half the states (in the next 10-15 years), we should have the incarceration machine rolled back to the mid 1980s, just six or seven years after the mass incarceration boom took off.

Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A... by tomc1985 on Thursday March 22, 2018 @05:53PM (#16653057)
Do you really want every brother and their mother with your data to have the ability to ruin your life like that?
Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A... by davvolun on Monday March 26, 2018 @10:15AM (#16679031)
Maybe I'm not being clear...

In the absence of clear, well-considered privacy laws (which I'm not the least bit hopeful for, particularly internationally consistent..), Google will have access to this data. As a randomly chosen user, there's probably nothing I can do about this (assumption being the average random user can't figure out how to enable e2e encryption). So Google will be data mining my data, if they choose to. And note I'm only choosing Google here because the user I replied to used Gmail as an example, I don't think Google is particularly unique or special in regards to using their user's data for profit.

Under those assumptions, if Google finds something illegal, they should say something, right?

There are a number of "outs" here. Privacy laws, Google giving me the ability to opt out/encrypt my data, ...

Do I want this? Hard no, but that's really not my point.

Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A... by dahdum on Thursday March 22, 2018 @04:45PM (#16652542)
GeekSquad actively searches for it, so they would probably be in the clear under this law.

Facebook knows many drug purchases are coordinated openly on college groups, even though their intent is not to facilitate them, by not searching out and reporting them they would be liable once this law is naturally expanded upon.

Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A... by davvolun on Monday March 26, 2018 @10:19AM (#16679066)
> Facebook knows many drug purchases are coordinated openly on college groups

How does Facebook know this, if they still have to search them out?

> ...once this law is naturally expanded upon.

Yeah, I can see that. Slippery slope and all that. On the other hand, I feel like e.g. Facebook needs to have an incentive to police their community. I, at least, don't see a clear path to prevent Cambridge Analytica-style abuses, not through legislative changes, not in this political environment...