The market prices for these banks made it clear that major investors either didn't read or didn't understand the data in the public filings.
That's impressive work, but I interpret that a little differently. There was definitely irrational exuberance going on, but plenty of major investors understood what was happening well before 2008. The reason the valuations were still out of whack is because having the correct data and the correct analysis isn't enough, you have to correctly forecast how the market will react. So there was an unfortunate feedback loop: many investors savvy enough to see the problem were not betting against it because there are far easier and more consistent ways of trading profitably.
This is why the most successful funds don't really try to replicate the process you're talking about. Their process is data and hypothesis agnostic. A lot of their work happens to align with the sort of analysis you've described here, but they don't start from the same place.
1) if you are a fund you just cant' sit out 3 years. Your fund will shut down as everyone will yank their money,. if its your own money then people will leave as you won't pay bonuses.
2) If you went short in 2006 then you wouldn't have survived until teh crash of late 2008.
> It's pretty easy to make way above average returns on the stock market.
This is just an absurd statement along the lines of its easy to build a billion dollar company just mimic what all the other billion dollar companies do.
Sorry for being so negative to your comment, but come on. That statement can't be seriously defended in any resonable manner.
Do you want to spend time finding the right investors or do you want to spend time reading 10Ks?
The fact that funds do worse than indexed etfs says more about fund incentives and investor savviness than it does about the effectiveness of this strategy.
Since the GFC a lot of macro bets in both US and EU have been bets on political will and central bank actions. In late 2010 Bank of America was technically insolvent (based on analysis similar to yours), but the Fed went to work and backstopped the market in a multitude of ways and the valuation soared. In 2012 I would have bet the farm that Greece was headed into bankruptcy, but the Greek people didn't revolt (as much as anticipated) and so the ECB effectively nationalized most Greek debt across the rest of the Eurozone. I'm no expert but I try to apply these lessons to all new modern crisis I hear about. Underfunded pensions will destroy certain states, or social security will be broke and unable to pay out benefits? Sure; we'll see.
What empirical evidence exists to support this belief?
What's done is done. It'll prove out either way in the next few years.
Bubbles existed before Keynesian policies.
That's not the evidence requested.
Buyout => What would it cost you to pay an insurer to take the liability off your hands (discount rate will basically be the replicating portfolio of government bonds).
Accounting => Depending on standard, the discount rate might just be the expected return on your portfolio
On a 30 year duration liability that could be a difference of over 200% between the different measures. Which is realistically right though?
Also, an accounting loss isn't always a "real" loss. For example, with the recent tax overhaul, some companies booked unexpected losses because they had significant carry forward losses. Those were reduced in value because the corporate tax rate went down. But essentially nothing changed -- yes the tax base and book value of these losses were adjusted, but no cash was lost.
They can also push revenue or profits back or pull it forward. It really is a jungle out there.
It probably wasn't rational but I was really scared.
I do know that 1) a payment system with transactions that take more than a few seconds and cost more than a few pennies is not a good payment system for most things. 2) I've never heard anyone talking about using crypto for anything but speculation or paying for ransomware. Even on the internet, I've mostly heard of speculation, ransomware prostitution and buying drugs. 3) Regulators don't like payment systems for ransomware, prostitution and buying drugs. 4) Assets whose prices are based on speculation eventually fall.
I could be missing something. As I said, I don't know much about crypto-currencies. Please nobody bet on my comment alone. Also, timing collapses is difficult. Bubbles can last for more than a decade.
The one distinguishing factor is that they have terrific brand value because of Musk, and this could mean that consumers would want their cars despite all the troubles they have. I think this unusual level of brand value is the confounding factor that muddies predictions and is unquantifiable. Brand value makes consumers make non-rational decisions. If it was any other car company with Tesla's numbers you'd be crazy to bet on them succeeding.
People who hear that say, Lexus are doing badly and have severe problems with their cars are going to go buy an Audi. People who want a Tesla so far are just waiting for a Tesla.
If you're buying something where a large part of the value is in the image/brand it's usually not fashionable to complain about it.
When a S10 breaks it's GM's fault. When a Tacoma breaks the owner didn't treat it right.
When a Kia breaks it's unreliable. When a BMW breaks that's just part of owning a BMW.
Tesla has cultivated an image (or rabid bunch of fanboys, depending on your perspective) where you're expected to put up with shoddy build quality and less than prompt service as part of the ownership experience so Tesla gets a pass on those things.
I'm not sure what they're investing in and how much more they have to invest so I don't have an opinion.
With those two simple adjustments, I saw that some big banks were in the hole by (combined) tens of billions of dollars.
The market prices for these banks made it clear that major investors either didn't read or didn't understand the data in the public filings.
Fun fact 1: My bank WaMu which was itself was maybe $0-$10B in the red so I immediately withdrew $2K in panic. I found that money hidden in my filing cabinet about 5 years ago.
Fun fact 2: What was even more crazy is that a famous private equity firm (I think TPG) had just dumped in billions of dollars into WaMu but that still didn't fill the hole (and why would such a big firm be less sophisticated than a nobody like me?)
Fun fact 3: FDIC had ~$50B at the time, which maybe wouldn't cover the losses at the pessimistic end of my estimates.
Fun fact 4: In accounting classes, I identified 3 very shady areas of accounting: options, off-balance sheet entities, and pensions. I believe the first two have since been fixed but I think pension accounting is still very shady so... beware.
Disclaimer: I studied finance and accounting in school and read 10-Ks in my spare time in the early 2000s so I have some knowledge of accounting shenanigans. I also had some experience in real estate. But that's about all the expertise it took.
(Several edits made to improve readability.)