Re:Revolution OS [video]
by javert on Sunday September 05, 2010 @07:37PM
(#1665438)
In this film, Richard Stallman presents his ideas very directly in interviews, so any left-wing bias is not really "hidden." This is a good way to learn about his views.
Re:Revolution OS [video]
by boyter on Monday September 06, 2010 @03:05AM
(#1666130)
I meant more towards the very anti large non free software business messages that are in it.
For example (all microsoft examples here off the top of my head)
Raymond giving the thousand yard stare at Microsoft exec
Bill Gates open letter
Richard talking about MS being a small player initially
The Microsoft free software refund meeting
All were made large closed source businesses look like the enemy. So the show is very biased especially towards Microsoft. Richard is indeed very open but the movie can be seen as a propaganda piece rather then purely factual.
Re:Revolution OS [video]
by javert on Monday September 06, 2010 @03:53PM
(#1667288)
Americans and Europeans mean different things by "left wing" and "right wing." In Europe, the spectrum goes from socialists to fascists. In America, the spectrum is much more narrow. It goes from a highly regulated state to a highly deregulated state, speaking economically. So in America, being against huge corporations is basically a left wing thing.
Re:Revolution OS [video]
by loup-vaillant on Monday September 06, 2010 @10:05AM
(#1666679)
The free/proprietary dichotomy is not the same as the left/right (or communist/capitalist) dichotomy. They're mostly orthogonal, in fact. Unless having any kind of ethic makes you left wing, but I doubt you think that.
Also, if the film doesn't look balanced, that's probably because the facts aren't. But to the point of looking like a mere propaganda piece? Only the background music gave me that impression.
Re:Revolution OS [video]
by jawngee on Monday September 06, 2010 @12:47AM
(#1665893)
Pretty interesting.
I actually think the most interesting thing is what happened to VA after the documentary. They've gone from a servers company to thinkgeek.com - weird.
Re:Revolution OS [video]
by points on Monday September 06, 2010 @02:54AM
(#1666111)
Yeah that scene was pretty good. Linus comes across as a really good guy. Stallman (as usual) comes across (to me anyway) as slightly unhinged and bitter.
Re:Revolution OS [video]
by loup-vaillant on Monday September 06, 2010 @10:14AM
(#1666704)
Could you define "insane", please? I've read the "Free Software, Free Society"[1] compilation, and Stallman appeared to me as very balanced and cautious (at least when it comes to his political views).
It is however very left wing, and fails to mention any flavor of BSD but you can't have it all.
For example (all microsoft examples here off the top of my head)
Raymond giving the thousand yard stare at Microsoft exec Bill Gates open letter Richard talking about MS being a small player initially The Microsoft free software refund meeting
All were made large closed source businesses look like the enemy. So the show is very biased especially towards Microsoft. Richard is indeed very open but the movie can be seen as a propaganda piece rather then purely factual.
Also, if the film doesn't look balanced, that's probably because the facts aren't. But to the point of looking like a mere propaganda piece? Only the background music gave me that impression.
I consider myself a progressive and am pro-capitalism.
I actually think the most interesting thing is what happened to VA after the documentary. They've gone from a servers company to thinkgeek.com - weird.
Here is a pretty good story about it: http://news.cnet.com/8301-13505_3-10413589-16.html
This is one of my favorite documentaries, would definitely like to see a sequel.
Someone should write an updated counter-point to the cathedral and the bazaar. A lot of it's theories seem dated nowadays.
What killed me was the Free Software Song live performance at the end. These are late 90's nerds at their nerdiest.
It was only once I dug deeper I realized how absolutely insane Richard Stallman is.
[1]: http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/fsfs/rms-essays.pdf