News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Consciousness Deniers by pdonis on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @10:11PM (#16644979)
> I've read and listened to what Dennett has to say on the matter, and the implication is exactly what the author states. It only seems like we are conscious, but we don't actually experience anything.

That is not what Dennett is saying. I have read all of his writings on consciousness, and he is quite clear (and in some places says in so many words) that he is not saying conscious experience does not exist. He is just saying that consciousness, real consciousness, is not like what the "mysterians" think it is like; it doesn't have all of the properties that people like the author of this article claim it has.

> Dennett also tried to deny that we have dream experiences

No, he didn't. He asked the question "are dreams experiences?" (in an article with that exact title that appears in the book Brainstorms, and more recently in other articles), and his conclusion was basically "it depends on what you mean by those words". Which illustrates another common fallacy that Dennett often has to rebut: the belief that saying something in ordinary language is sufficient to pin down a precise concept that can be explored and tested.

> Taking Dennett seriously entails denying any sort of internal experience

It does no such thing. Whatever giving Dennett's views a fair shake entails, you clearly have not met the requirements.

There are no comments on this comment yet.