Re:California should emulate Tokyo, where housing stayed ahe...
by leetcrew on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @07:13PM
(#16643337)
the ROI for stocks would have to be significantly higher than the ROI from real estate for it to make sense for a working/middle class person to invest in stocks instead of the structure they live in. you need to pay for housing either way.
Re:California should emulate Tokyo, where housing stayed ahe...
by jogjayr on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @07:37PM
(#16643532)
> you need to pay for housing either way.
Yes but you don't have to pay the same amounts. There's a reason "rent-or-buy" calculators exist.
Re:California should emulate Tokyo, where housing stayed ahe...
by com2kid on Thursday March 22, 2018 @02:05PM
(#16651033)
Once owned outright, a home also serves as insurance against economic downturns.
Rent, 4 or 5 year economic slump and people are out of a home.
Ownership doesn't lead to this. Even mortgages have more forgiveness for late payment than most rental agreements.
Multi-generational property ownership also helps. Buy a good house now, and your kids/grand kids have insurance against economic downturns.
Re:California should emulate Tokyo, where housing stayed ahe...
by closeparen on Thursday March 22, 2018 @03:38AM
(#16646587)
The insane levels of year-over-year appreciation/rent hikes make any calculator say "buy" in expensive major cities, regardless of the difference in cost today.
Re:California should emulate Tokyo, where housing stayed ahe...
by jogjayr on Thursday March 22, 2018 @12:08PM
(#16649842)
Citation needed. That's not the case in the SF Bay Area, Manhattan/Brooklyn, Vancouver, or Toronto. The new tax bill's provisions to cap mortgage interest deductions has further tilted the balance against expensive houses.
Re:California should emulate Tokyo, where housing stayed ahe...
by dahdum on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @09:55PM
(#16644830)
That depends almost entirely on the rent to value in their local market, and is far more volatile than index funds.
I rented a 1.3m home in CA for $3,500/month, made no sense to buy at that level other than a forced savings program.
Re:California should emulate Tokyo, where housing stayed ahe...
by branchless on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @07:41PM
(#16643563)
People don't typically have access to leverage for an index fund. Most debt is printed for purchasing land.
Re:California should emulate Tokyo, where housing stayed ahe...
by williw on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @07:22PM
(#16643408)
Also no tax incentives for investing in stock compared to real estate.
Re:California should emulate Tokyo, where housing stayed ahe...
by lotsofpulp on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @08:04PM
(#16643810)
401k, defines benefit pensions, HSA, IRA, 529 plans, etc. There are tons of government subsidies for the stock market, and not just via tax incentives.
Re:California should emulate Tokyo, where housing stayed ahe...
by dahdum on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @10:02PM
(#16644880)
What tax incentive is there for real estate other than the small SALT deduction? A mortgage is just leverage, you can similarly deduct margin loan interest (with no cap other than investment income IIRC).
Buy an index fund.