News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by vowelless on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @11:43AM (#16639070)
Relatedly, I have been reading an enlightening book: The Triumph of Christianity [0]. It's a very interesting insight into why Christianity took over Europe in the first place. One of the points made is that paganism was a loose confederation of religions that didn't demand exclusivity. Christianity was an evangelical, exclusivist religion which provides a full alternative world view. However, the early Christians, the author alleges, were less educated and oppressed (non intellectuals ).

While it may be good that Europe is going secular, I think without a strong, exclusivist moral ideology at the center, Europe will be susceptible to an Evangelical exclusivist ideology (Christinity 2.0). Or, as the book highlights, perhaps the population should be a lot more educated (which Europe seems to be doing well) and this education level sustained across generations.

> In the UK, only 7% of young adults identify as Anglican, fewer than the 10% who categorise themselves as Catholic. Young Muslims, at 6%, are on the brink of overtaking those who consider themselves part of the country’s established church.

Islam is an Evangelical exclusivist ideology and has strong state backings today. Billions of dollars are used by Islamic states to evangelize the religion. I don't think Christianity has done that in a 100 years or so. If the younger generation is more Muslim than Christian, and the majority is without an exclusivist ideology, and state backed evangelism continues, it will be interesting to see how, over generations, Muslim ideology becomes more mainstream.

As a secular humanist, former Muslim, I hope we actually establish secular humanism with religious frevor (make it the state ideology) to make sure human rights and human progress is sustained.

[0] https://www.npr.org/2018/03/20/595161200/author-traces-chris...

Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by verylittlemeat on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:06PM (#16639368)
"People can't be free to think for themselves because they'll make stupid decisions"

I know you're not making that argument specifically but that's sort of what it boils down to right? That bad systems which focus their power will win out over good systems which don't. It's like the argument that keeps coming up in the China VS USA threads where people worry about the US because it handicaps itself in science with its regulations and concerns over ethics.

I don't particularly disagree with what you're saying because it feels true but it should be pointed out that it's an awfully nice excuse for people with power to see themselves as benevolent overlords.

Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by mistermann on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:14PM (#16639491)
The more real (and observable today imho) problem is: in general, people aren't really good at, interested in, or have time for thinking deeply and critically, and some things matter, a lot. So if they can't (or won't) think about these things themselves, and you remove a religious rule, it creates a vacuum where anyone or any "-ism" can enter and replace religion's influence on public behavior.
Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by armandososa on Saturday March 24, 2018 @10:50AM (#16666843)
It's not the rules, it's about the faith. e.g. If I (honestly) believe that all human beings were made equal in the image of God (whatever that may be) that would affect the way I treat people.

Some rules will came out of that belief: like "don't lie" and "don't kill" but, in it's purest form, religion is not about rules, and the fact that people don't know that means that religious institutions have failed.

Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by mistermann on Sunday March 25, 2018 @02:58AM (#16671108)
That's a fine theory, but to claim you know this with certainty I think is a much larger claim than you realize. What exactly makes humans behave they way they do is extremely complex - some people may behave exactly for the reason you describe, others may not, anyone that says they know for sure is not telling the truth (although that doesn't necessarily mean they're lying).
Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by verylittlemeat on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:19PM (#16639537)
What kinds of religious rules do you feel keep which types of behaviors in check? (the ones you see as most important for society)

I'm just curious what you consider, not looking for an argument or debate necessarily.

Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by mistermann on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @02:53PM (#16641205)
In general, honesty and following the rules I think correlates to religion. Religion isn't necessary, but I believe something formal is necessary. I see no reason whatsoever to believe that people are going to each come to similar fairly optimum decisions individually, and plenty of reasons to believe they won't.
Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by Balgair on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @04:49PM (#16642259)
I think it's more like:

"People don't think through their decisions very well"

The OP points out that there are many nations that put in big funding for Islam in the west and around the world. Here in the US, the Mormon church is very similar. Other examples abound. More money means that it is more likely that the local mosque/temple is well funded, has free food, basketball courts, a gym, daycare, counseling services, etc. If the other local centers for religion or other social functions are not as well funded and stocked, it's not hard to see people flocking to the mosque/temple. The proximity will undoubtedly lead to conversions, or at least toleration of the religion. At first this is not so bad, but we all know the more extremist views of many religions can quickly take hold and may degrade women's rights, children's education, healthcare access, and justice decisions (see upstate NY). I am NOT saying this will happen or that any one religion is wholly better; we all have faults.

Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by vowelless on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @01:55PM (#16640654)
I think perhaps in parallel to you point, move towards centralization tends to overpower confederations. Incidentedly, this point is also made in the Federalist papers and I believe Wealth of Nations which argues that centralization leads to stability and robustness.

Exclusivity and evangelism helped centralize Christianity in comparison with the pagans.

Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by thevardanian on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @11:50AM (#16639145)
I honestly think that the whole oppressed conversion theory is wrong, for the most part. For most of Christian, and Islam the history was a top down conversion.

Furthermore India, and Hinduism stands in stark contrast to this narrative. Especially considering the whole caste system narrative.

Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by vowelless on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @11:54AM (#16639201)
The author cites an early critique of Christianity by a pagan intellectual named Celsus, who criticizes the early Christian evangelists from running away from engaging in intellectual debates. Also one thing to keep in mind is that a very small number of people were actually educated at this time. The vast majority of people were not educated, slaves, etc. He also alleges that it is possible many of the early Christian converts were women, who were shunned from the power structures and oppressed.
Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by pmarreck on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @11:58AM (#16639259)
I was curious about this individual (my new ancient-hero-of-the-day) and came across this https://streetapologist.wordpress.com/2014/11/01/celsus-vs-t... for anyone else curious. Also

> secular humanist, former Muslim

My opinion is not evidence, but here it is anyway: You made the right decision, here.

Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by kamaal on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:30PM (#16639694)
India, what you know of today, isn't India what existed before Islam or christianity started spreading into Asia. The historical India, is now split over Afghanistan, Pakistan, Certain parts of Iran, Bangladesh, Nepal, Sri Lanka, Certain parts of Tibet and Bhutan.

Bulk of those countries now is populated mostly by Muslims, Christians and Buddhist. The Muslim and Christian population in India itself is >15%. So >50% of the original population, moved to new religions. And you keep hearing of people moving to other religions from Hinduism all the time.

This is a major source of political strife in India today.

The caste system did/is doing enormous irreparable damage to the Indian society and has done over the ages. The moment any new religion was available people have moved on to it in mass numbers.

The oppressed people always move on to what works for them. Don't blame them, nobody changes their identity that easily. Its only when things go beyond bearable do people make these decisions. And beyond all any conversion to a new religion is a late process, the early process involves divorce from the existing religion.

You can't stop change of heart.

Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by amriksohata on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @03:47PM (#16641642)
Agreed though the caste system was exploited by the British to divide and rule, the upper caste brahmins used to be poor beggars that the other castes would goto for advise and the British saw this and corrupted them as they saw they had authority
Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by lbotos on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @11:58AM (#16639260)
I'm naive and happy to learn more, but my understanding is the "top down" conversion was for control, no? It's much easier to control an empire if everyone agrees to the same set of rules?
Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by yters on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @11:55AM (#16639211)
A lot of Christian growth came from enslaved or exiled Christians. However, once adopted by the king, then it became more top down. Islam, on the other hand, mostly spread by conquest, hence "religion of the sword."
Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by dragonwriter on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:27PM (#16639644)
> A lot of Christian growth came from enslaved or exiled Christians. However, once adopted by the king, then it became more top down.

Once Christianity became the state religion of the Roman Empire in the 4th C, its spread was largely by conquest and top-down, both within Europe and through European colonialism.

Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by yters on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @01:09PM (#16640159)
Even after the Roman Empire collapsed in that same century?
Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by dragonwriter on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @01:32PM (#16640451)
> Even after the Roman Empire collapsed in that same century?

It didn't. It split shortly after, and the post-split Western Empire collapsed nearly a century later, the Eastern Empire about a millenium after that, and both had top-down imposed Christianity throughout their domains before falling, as did many of their successors.

Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by yters on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @04:06PM (#16641839)
How can you explain European Christianity with top down imposed rule if the Western Empire collapsed before the medieval ages? What is doing the imposing?
Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by icebraining on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @05:17PM (#16642506)
Many peoples converted to fall on the good graces of the eastern Roman empire and stop being trampled on so much. For example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christianization_of_Bulgaria
Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by dragonwriter on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @05:13PM (#16642476)
> How can you explain European Christianity with top down imposed rule if the Western Empire collapsed before the medieval ages?

Much of it by Francia, whose first King converted to Christianity in 496, and which rapidly became the dominant power in Western Europe.

Re:'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Chri... by masonic on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @09:37PM (#16644700)

  Much of it by Francia, whose first King converted to Christianity in 496
... which is 20 years after the Western empire fell.