Re:The US Army’s costly quest for the perfect radio
by gamblor956 on Tuesday March 20, 2018 @03:25PM
(#16631720)
I have a handheld walkie-talkie radio from REI that can transmit 10-20 miles from the top of a hill in not-perfect conditions (and about 1-2 miles in forested terrain), so I think your range estimates are off by an order of magnitude for high-powered transmissions.
Re:The US Army’s costly quest for the perfect radio
by vvanders on Tuesday March 20, 2018 @03:39PM
(#16631834)
Nah, he's pretty on the mark. I'm lucky to make it into the repeater ~15mi down the road from me(50W on both side) because it's not at the top of a mountain. Unless you're talking HF(which he covers) you're basically still constrained by line-of-sight.
More power just pushes you through small objects(trees, buildings, etc) depending on wavelength.
I'm not arguing with the rest of your post, I'm sure there is way more fraud, waste and abuse then we can imagine going on. But the laws of physics still apply and if you want transmit a signal far, you need a power source bigger than what people can carry. Even a vehicle mounted and powered radio wouldn't be able to transmit 10-20 miles unless you were sitting on top of a hill in otherwise perfect conditions.