Re:Religious Outlier
by adolph on Saturday September 04, 2010 @01:08PM
(#1662990)
This is a weird piece of chart-junk. Where is the giant China ball on the graph? Why is Hinduism grouped under other? Why separate out Catholic and Protestant?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I would guess:
-China didn't allow the Gallup survey.
-Hinduism is predominantly practiced in just a few countries, and India has a lot of non-Hindus.
-Because it was responsible for a lot of historical conflict & indicates a significant difference in religious structure. Also an American paper is more likely to Eurocentric.
As usual, when discussing popular anthropology, this reveals the writer's prejudices more than anything else.
The ordinary protestant would hate being confused for a Catholic, especially when a chart listing GDPs is concerned.
On the last one, what's likely to be confusing from an American point of view is that it isn't actually Catholic and Protestant groups, but Catholic and non-Catholic, with a large part of the latter being Eastern Orthodox (Ukraine, Greece, Serbia, Romania).