Re:Ask HN: Did Facebook really do something wrong?
by epmaybe on Tuesday March 20, 2018 @11:21AM
(#16629311)
When you say abused, do you mean that the campaign did not violate it in 2012 but took advantage of the lenience Facebook allowed them? Thanks
Re:Ask HN: Did Facebook really do something wrong?
by danso on Tuesday March 20, 2018 @11:29AM
(#16629394)
According to what campaign workers told the NYT, the harvesting of data seems most certainly to have violated FB’s TOS, especially regarding the storing of data for reasons other than caching performance: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16624506
But FB has the right to decide when to enforce TOS or not. It seems they never did so, not just for Obama but for other operators as well. Pretty sure most FB users would be surprised that their data was knowingly analyzed by a third party as thoroughly as the NYT article describes, with FB’s knowledge.
Saying that people could just write a web scraper anyway is a bullshit rationalization. The technical barrier is high enough that it would make it an extremely costly option, certainly more costly than all the other data sources that campaigns traditionally use.
FB may not have outright committed evil, but they sure didn’t seem to prioritize safety for their users. And that’s enough on which to consider judging them accordingly.