News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The ability to correct errors in GPLv2 compliance: the ri... by toyg on Tuesday March 20, 2018 @10:27AM (#16628817)
> Are there copyright holders engaging in abusive litigation?

Some enforcement efforts have been controversial, particularly the VmWare suit and other efforts by SFConservancy. I wouldn't call them trolls, but a lot of people think they are too heavy-handed.

On the other hand, with nobody wielding a stick, there is no real incentive not to abuse free licenses - which is exactly why the GPL exists in the first place.

Re:The ability to correct errors in GPLv2 compliance: the ri... by LukeShu on Tuesday March 20, 2018 @12:04PM (#16629777)
The SF Conservancy has always done exactly what CA/Cisco/HPE/Microsoft/SAP/SUSE are now pledging to do. It's part of their Principles of Community-Oriented GPL Enforcement.

Whether or not you think they are too heavy-handed, or think they are trolls: SF Conservancy-like behavior isn't the type of behavior being addressed here.

Re:The ability to correct errors in GPLv2 compliance: the ri... by throwaway2048 on Tuesday March 20, 2018 @10:29AM (#16628845)
How are they too heavily handed? the only thing they ask for in negotiation and lawsuits is GPL compliance, they dont demand money, or anything else.

If following the license is too much to ask for, what exactly does "not heavy handed" mean?

Re:The ability to correct errors in GPLv2 compliance: the ri... by kuschku on Tuesday March 20, 2018 @02:54PM (#16631453)
> If following the license is too much to ask for, what exactly does "not heavy handed" mean?

The "enforcement" that Torvalds wants is what you see with Android today: Everyone ships blobs of kernel builds, with the source never released.

Re:The ability to correct errors in GPLv2 compliance: the ri... by crankylinuxuser on Tuesday March 20, 2018 @03:20PM (#16631682)
And that shit needs to stop now.

If I want to bloody recompile the LK on my phone to install a proper linux, that or other GPL tools shouldn't be blockers.

Re:The ability to correct errors in GPLv2 compliance: the ri... by anon1385 on Tuesday March 20, 2018 @11:25AM (#16629344)
> they dont demand money

A linux developer demanding money from GPL violators is (seemingly) what triggered this action. See http://www.zdnet.com/article/linux-beats-internal-legal-thre...

>McHardy has sued companies for Linux GPLv2 violations in over 38 cases. In one, he'd requested a contractual penalty of €1.8 million. The company also claimed McHardy had already received over €2 million from his actions.

>what exactly does "not heavy handed" mean

It means not permanently revoking their licence to use the code again, even once they have become compliant. It's a common complaint made about the GPLv2 which was clarified in GPLv3

Re:The ability to correct errors in GPLv2 compliance: the ri... by throwaway2048 on Tuesday March 20, 2018 @11:28AM (#16629378)
The poster i was replying to was talking about SFC, not that case.