News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Epic Games releases $12M worth of Paragon assets for free by abiox on Monday March 19, 2018 @12:37PM (#16619813)
> I'm just pointing out that this isn't free for the sake of being benevolent. It's free for the sake of capturing market share.

this seems like it could be a false dichotomy. it's not obvious why it can't be both.

Re:Epic Games releases $12M worth of Paragon assets for free by wwalser on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:56PM (#16621021)
Benevolent: "(of an organization) serving a charitable rather than a profit-making purpose."

That's not how this word works. We can use another one.

I hasten to add, again, that I'm attributing nothing pejorative. I'm glad Epic have done this. It's great marketing that may be helpful to lots of people.

Re:Epic Games releases $12M worth of Paragon assets for free by abiox on Monday March 19, 2018 @03:00PM (#16621901)
"benevolent" wasn't being used to describe the organization, it was being used to describe a particular action.
Re:Epic Games releases $12M worth of Paragon assets for free by awesomepeter on Tuesday March 20, 2018 @08:19AM (#16627845)
The issue is this action isn't benevolent. It's nice, but as said previously it's to promote their engine. So they will profit from it indirectly.

If on the other hand they would release the assets without strings attached (for use with any game engine / in any way) then I'd say this word would apply.

Re:Epic Games releases $12M worth of Paragon assets for free by abiox on Tuesday March 20, 2018 @10:20AM (#16628753)
and my point was that this seemed like a false dichotomy.
Re:Epic Games releases $12M worth of Paragon assets for free by squarefoot on Monday March 19, 2018 @02:30PM (#16621506)
True. A dichotomy cannot explain for example tax deductible donations: they're obviously self advertising at much lower cost than a real PR campaign, still they benefit someone, so we probably should use a trichotomy like "I'm doing good even if it has a sustainable cost" - "I'm doing good only if it somehow benefits me as well" - "I'm not doing good because being evil brings even more profit than the above".