News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by hliyan on Monday March 19, 2018 @11:49AM (#16619308)
I read the text of the ad without making any assumptions, and I was hard pressed to find any fault with it. The only problem appears when you factor in who's saying it and what you _think_ the ad is saying.

Edit: in case readers assume I'm being racist in some way: I'm a Sri Lankan national.

Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by klenwell on Monday March 19, 2018 @12:54PM (#16620017)
I checked it out thinking maybe I was quick to assume the worst.

On review, it looks and sounds pretty dog-whistley to me. Worse than I expected.

As a Sri Lankan national, you may be missing some of the nativist overtones. "Undeserving" in particular is a loaded term in American public political discourse.

For an especially pernicious application, see:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welfare_queen

This is a meme that still resonates with many people in America. It still resonates with me, as an ugly example of the way misleading rhetoric get deployed to stigmatize an underrepresented political class. This term immediately evokes associations like these.

Also, the color scheme and typography: seems designed to evoke a not very enlightened response. Definitely not embracing the light and airy look-and-feel I generally associate with progressive tech community.

Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by bassman9000 on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:07PM (#16620224)
the color scheme and typography

I'd say it's designed to draw your attention. And boy it did.

Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by archagon on Monday March 19, 2018 @07:04PM (#16624189)
Yeah, the red, black, and white color scheme was certainly not chosen by accident.
Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by hliyan on Tuesday March 20, 2018 @02:56AM (#16626466)
Yup, I do admit I may be missing some of the finer nuances here...
Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by lightbyte on Monday March 19, 2018 @11:53AM (#16619343)
I think the name of the organization that is running the ad is also a problem. They seem to be trying to co-opt the "progressive" label for something that is completely opposite to what it is supposed to (over the last few years) stand for.

I can't tell if they are intentionally doing that for nefarious reasons. Imagine seeing a "Conservatives for repealing the 2nd amendment" ad. I would assume they have some ulterior motives there.

Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by mfoy_ on Monday March 19, 2018 @11:56AM (#16619377)
I think the ad is utterly genius (in a nefarious way) because it's making me want to play devil's advocate soooo badly. The authors are clearly trying to get people to conflate "H1-B abuse" with "immigration".

People can be against H1-B abuse and NOT be anti-immigration.

Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by Symmetry on Monday March 19, 2018 @12:10PM (#16619506)
It was really weird to me when people in the 21st century started calling themselves to differentiate themselves from other sorts of liberals. Modern progressives and the progressives of the Progressive era share many features but traditional progressives were strongly associated with moral paternalism and eugenics. Seeing people I would have called liberals start calling themselves progressive was as jarring as Trump's use of "America First". And I think that nativism isn't unknown to modern progressives. I think Bernie Sanders is commonly considered a progressive and he was very down on immigrants depressing native worker's wages.
Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by jnbiche on Monday March 19, 2018 @12:22PM (#16619626)
> he was very down on immigrants depressing native worker's wages.

I'm not a Sanders supporter, but just wanted to point out that one can be both pro-immigrant (wanting to increase general immigrant quotas) and against programs like H1B that are designed to suppress salaries in specific industries.

Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by Symmetry on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:18PM (#16620357)
Well, most Sanders supporters are way more pro-immigrant than he is so being pro-Sanders doesn't really mean that much here. There was some great reporting in I think the New York times a while ago on the beliefs of the supporters of various presidential contenders. And yes, you can certainly be against a certain policy without being anti-immigration. I'm for drastically expanding US immigration but replacing H1Bs with programs that don't tie people to a particular employer is something I would support.
Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by ergothus on Monday March 19, 2018 @12:21PM (#16619614)
I hadn't known that historical perspective, thanks. I was glad when the term started to become popular because the US post-Reagan era had made "liberal" into a term used to insult and degrade without considering the actual ideas of any instance.

I was shocked at Sanders amount of success, because I had grown up believing that the US public would immediately discount any associating with the word "socialist" (even by those that actually had beliefs not far from socialist views, and even allowing that Sanders positions aren't actually 'socialist' as used in Europe).

I suspect "progressive" was embraced for such reasons, but given how much I've been wrong about most anything political on the past decade+, I'd love to have actual evidence.

Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by drb91 on Monday March 19, 2018 @05:46PM (#16623534)
"Liberal" isn't a terribly useful word in the US these days, given how wide the democratic party's non-existent platform is.

I agree "progressive" isn't the most useful re-use of the word, but I would emphatically call it anti-nativist (or rather, pro-globalist) these days, or just "leftist".

Political labels in general are ill-fitted to static definitions. People are always stealing terms, twisting others, for demagogic needs. "liberal", "conservative", "progressive", "leftist", and "alt-right" are all pretty terrible for anything but, uhh, cultural identification, and don't indicate much of anything about you politically.

Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by scythe on Monday March 19, 2018 @12:31PM (#16619740)
You used [1] but didn't provide a link at the bottom. Did you forget to cite something?
Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by Symmetry on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:12PM (#16620277)
Oops, I was going to list an example then decided not to. Thanks for pointing that out.
Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by bassman9000 on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:12PM (#16620279)
liberal used to mean economically and socially liberal, that is, free market economy and let people live their lives. Now we have to call them classical liberals. What does progressive stands for? Who decides what progress is? Is increasing the quality of life of 10 by decreasing the quality of life of 100 progress?
Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by swebs on Monday March 19, 2018 @12:14PM (#16619535)
On the contrary, their stance is more in line with the traditional view of progressivism. It's only fairly recently that free market capitalists tried to push for open borders and mass immigration under the guise of "progress". There's a simple reason why the big tech companies want more immigrants. It suppresses wages. It changes the dynamics of supply and demand of the workforce in order to take power away from workers and give it to employers.

If you're against the 1%, you should be against these neoliberal immigration policies.

Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by maoistinquisitr on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:39PM (#16620745)
What's changed is the needs of the political classes. The democrat party has been in something of a death spiral for decades (arguably since the 50s) and is critically dependant on imported voters. Without the massive immigration that has happened post-1965, the political party configuration would have almost certainly fractured and reformed along quite different lines by now. But ongoing immigration has kept the democrat party in its rather ossified form highly competitive (as they lost "American" voters, they gained immigrant votes).

This is why they were so terrified of Bernie Sanders. He got a lot of support from working class whites who have been trending Republican for decades. But a figure like Sanders would derail the agenda (immigration and all) that is keeping a never ending stream of Kennedys in power.

Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by drb91 on Monday March 19, 2018 @11:57AM (#16619391)
Yea, this is a conversation that people should be having, the "progressive" part seems to just be a straight up lie/misdirection. Hard to take it seriously.
Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by mfoy_ on Monday March 19, 2018 @11:51AM (#16619330)
Generally speaking, it's not wrong. There's historically always been friction between labour and management.

I don't know what the ideal "solution" is, though the authors of the ad seems to thinks it involves immigrants. :\

Re:Anti-Immigrant Ads Aimed at Tech Workers Are Running on P... by abandonliberty on Monday March 19, 2018 @12:26PM (#16619673)
If you are an employee, you should protect your interests. This includes ensuring that you, your children, and your fellow citizens are hired preferentially to importing labor.

The 'better future' people many immigrate for includes higher standards of living for similar work. They are willing to work for less because they believe citizenship is worth something. That 'better future' only exists if the country maintains this inequality by ensuring that citizens are hired first where possible.

Issues of globalization, birthplace lottery, and wealth inequality aside; these policies are in your favor if you are an employee, immigrant or not. Conversely, these policies hurt the company's bottom line by preventing hiring of the most cost efficient labor.

The backlash against this message is weaponized political correctness and/or employees speaking out against their best interests.