I'm not saying vitamin D isn't involved; I'm just wondering whether it's the whole story. Is this single nucleotide change in SLC24A5 really the only way to decrease melanin production without having other harmful side effects? Naively I would expect lots of ways to have a loss-of-function mutation; why is this one so common? Sexual selection could be a factor, but that is not politically correct to say.
> Is this single nucleotide change in SLC24A5 really the only way to decrease melanin production without having other harmful side effects? Naively I would expect lots of ways to have a loss-of-function mutation
In Asia, light skin evolved separately and is using different genes.
That is the driving force for lighter skin (unless your diet is mostly fish, such as the Inuit). Skin gets darker again when migration towards sunnier climates happens: while UV light is essential for the synthesis of D3, it also destroys folic acid / vitamin B9 [1], which is essential when the neural tube of a fetus is being formed.
And since this mutation is so very visible, maybe here sexual selection plays a role, just like it is suspected with blond hair?
1: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/03/140321095240.h...