News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Europeans evolved white skin (2015) by masklinn on Saturday March 17, 2018 @12:39PM (#16607715)
> So vitamin D is the driving factor: either you lose melanin, or become lactose tolerant

That doesn't make any sense, unless it's reinforced milk contains almost no vitamin D (2 IU per 100g, recommendations are 2500 IU/day for children aged 1~3 to 4000 IU/day for adults). Plus there are lactase persistence clusters outside Europe which make even less sense given the Vitamin D hypothesis (e.g. arabian peninsula, Western Africa).

Lactase persistence overlaps much better with historical pastoralism, which makes a lot more sense: milk is high in calories[0], being able to use these calories when they're available is advantageous. Plus it also provides some fat, proteins and B2, B12 and Calcium micro-nutrients in appreciable quantities (15, 20 and 10% DRI respectively for un-fortified whole milk).

edit: even more so local, small-scale pastoralism: before refrigeration you'd have had to consume the milk within hours so either a few familial animals or a small herd at the tribal/village level. That could also explain why some cultures have a history of dairy products but not of consuming milk directly (and thus low lactase persistence).

[0] cow milk is ~250kJ/100g, and much of that is locked in the ~5g of lactose

There are no comments on this comment yet.