News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Author Simon Singh Puts Up a Fight in the War on Science by ugh on Friday September 03, 2010 @12:16PM (#1660066)
Authority can be useful. I know, it’s usually scoffed at because there is a fallacy named after it. Yet there is no conceivable way in which you can be an expert in all the big fields and little niches of science. You have to use the authority shortcut. You have to find people who you can trust and let them figure it out for you. That’s just a reality of the human condition.

All Singh says is that you should trust people who deal with the topic at hand every day of their life and who use the scientific method. I’m not really sure who else you should trust when you want answers to your questions. The scientific method is certainly not perfect but do you know of any better alternative? I don’t.

Re:Author Simon Singh Puts Up a Fight in the War on Science by josefresco on Friday September 03, 2010 @12:50PM (#1660198)
I couldn't agree more about your statement regarding authority. But oppose the behavior of trusting only those who "deal" with a subject every day. History shows many medical and scientific advances were made by smart people working outside their field.
Re:Author Simon Singh Puts Up a Fight in the War on Science by ugh on Friday September 03, 2010 @01:59PM (#1660448)
If you are not an expert there is no reliable way for you to tell whether someone outside the field is a genius or a crank. Both is possible (though I would argue that the cranks vastly outnumber the geniuses) but if even the experts inside the field are unable to tell the difference there is no chance in hell you can. That’s the big problem.

I doesn’t really help you that scientific discoveries are from time to time made by people outside the respective fields, if you are not an expert you have no way to discern the good stuff from the bad stuff.