Re:Our Interesting Call with CTS-Labs
by Ajedi32 on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:49PM
(#16598478)
Perhaps I'm missing something, but don't these vulnerabilities require root to exploit?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
That is the attack surface for a secure coprocessor vulnerability!
It's also what makes the vulnerabilities not-that-bad. It's just another "peripheral not properly handling firmware updates" thing, which are all over the place.
I mean, it's cool from a security research perspective, the PSP isn't just some random keyboard/HDD, but the severity seems overstated.
I'm not here to argue that CTS-Labs or Viceroy didn't overstate the vulnerabilities. Surely, Viceroy did! They said the stock was heading for zero!
I'm saying that the inverse argument, that the vulnerabilities are "pedestrian" and not worth making noise about, is at least equally false.
Unfortunately, the day of the announcement, several people trafficked in opinions based on CTS-Labs white paper --- which any skilled reader knew immediately, just from the format, wasn't a technical explanation --- that these vulnerabilities were non-issues. If I see people repeating that notion, I'm going to point out: the equivalent vulnerability in the iPhone platform would be front-page news.