https://www.us-cert.gov/ncas/alerts/TA18-074A
and has more interesting technical details.
It's true that both this and previously reports technically involved "anonymous officials in the DHS", in the sense that alert doesn't name any specific officials, but the phrase "anonymous officials" is usually associated with leaks, not official announcements...
I’ve seen unsecured electrical substation and industrial controls, but not actively compromised.
…I was writing a rather long comment that tried to defend the Post story as, in retrospect, probably true, in light of the current report and other more recent showing a pattern. (In particular, the current report actually shows a VNC connection to some kind of generator system, though presumably not Burlington Electric's.) However, the Post's own followup report [1] suggested that (contrary to the company's original statement) the government had not found any indicators on the Burlington Electric laptop that were uniquely linked to Grizzly Steppe:
U.S. officials are continuing to investigate the laptop. In the
course of their investigation, though, they have found on the device
a package of software tools commonly used by online criminals to
deliver malware. The package, known as Neutrino, does not appear
to be connected with Grizzly Steppe, which U.S. officials have
identified as the Russian hacking operation. The FBI, which declined
to comment, is continuing to investigate how the malware got onto
the laptop.
Initially, company officials publicly said they had detected code
that had been linked by the Department of Homeland Security to
Grizzly Steppe.
I still don't think this does much of anything to invalidate the current story. It seems like that was mainly a mistake on the company's part, as they incorrectly treated indicators that were non-uniquely linked to a hacking campaign as evidence it was targeted by that campaign. They then reported this to various authorities, and the information apparently found its way via the state police to one of the state's US senators - probably without the details being vetted by anyone with relevant experience. But both the the US-CERT report and the Symantec report provide evidence of an ongoing, targeted campaign against energy facilities (which, for that matter, was active at the time of the Post report). And one would expect that both reports originate from people that do basically know what they're talking about.[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/russi...
US utilities and US officials have been in Ukraine for a while working with these utilities on the assumption that what happens in Ukraine will eventually happen on their home turf.
This is actually a thing and it's an important move that officials are calling people out now.
https://www.wired.com/2016/03/inside-cunning-unprecedented-h...
https://www.wired.com/2016/01/everything-we-know-about-ukrai...
Er, no. The story was retracted because what the original version said that authorities claimed was not what authorities actually claimed. It was a journalistic backtrack (WaPo retracted their original reporting), not a government backtrack.
An erroneous media report of the government making an accusation is not an example of the government making the accusation that would, then, invalidate a description of the government later actually making a similar accusation as being unprecedented.
Here's an example paragraph:
Rep. Peter Welch (D-Vt.) said the attack shows how rampant Russian hacking is. “It’s systemic, relentless, predatory,” Welch said . “They will hack everywhere, even Vermont, in pursuit of opportunities to disrupt our country. We must remain vigilant, which is why I support President Obama’s sanctions against Russia and its attacks on our country and what it stands for.”
and another
Officials said that it is unclear when the code entered the Vermont utility’s computer, and that an investigation will attempt to determine the timing and nature of the intrusion.
What US officials are claiming here is very straightforward - the journalists simply quoted them directly in many cases, even the anonymous ones. And the story makes clear this story came from many different sources.
So no, it wasn't a simply journalistic error. The government made precise, clear claims multiple times from multiple officials - and then the story was retracted. But only after many people had seen it.
> So no, it wasn't a simply journalistic error.
Yes, it was.
Not exactly what you said, they hacked a utility computer but not one connected to the grid.
>> story sourced to anonymous officials in the DHS
This is Reuters so odds are that someone @DHS made that claim. Even if Reuters screwed up, DHS would probably call AP and deny the claim.
What should be said is that USA almost certainly does the same, and it makes sense to be able to shut down your adversary once "war" starts.
They never carried weight for me. The "evil Russians" angle has always been about disinforming and misdirecting the public.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/russi...
A code associated with the Russian hacking operation dubbed Grizzly Steppe by the Obama administration has been detected within the system of a Vermont utility, according to U.S. officials.
... but ...
Editor’s Note: An earlier version of this story incorrectly said that Russian hackers had penetrated the U.S. electric grid. Authorities say there is no indication of that so far. The computer at Burlington Electric that was hacked was not attached to the grid.
Generally speaking, anonymously sourced stories in western news outlets about Russian hacking have a very high propensity to collapse or get quietly retracted days later. The DHS is particularly notorious for this: they also claimed Russia hacked various election related systems in multiple states, but the states themselves investigated and said the DHS was wrong.
I cite some more examples in this blog post:
https://blog.plan99.net/%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%B0%D0%B2%D0%B4%D0%B0...
Glenn Greenwald also wrote extensively about this problem.
So now we have an "unprecedented" story sourced to anonymous officials in the DHS, making the entirely false claim that this is the first time US officials have accused Russia of hacking the electrical grid. The cited evidence is a Symantec report that didn't name anyone in particular.
Is it possible Russia is doing this? Of course. I would be, if I were Putin. But I'd also be doing it if I were the leader of Iran or North Korea or China. Perhaps all of them are doing it.
Regardless of the truth, this sort of story should have no credibility with anyone by now. There have been far too many false stories about Russian hacking published for them to carry weight.