Re:Which weight will lift first as the rope is pulled?
by brlewis on Friday September 03, 2010 @11:01AM
(#1659781)
Your conclusion is incorrect given your assumptions. You are assuming no floor, in which case all the weights will rise. Only the man will fall. I think the problem was intended to include a floor that simply isn't drawn.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Which weight will lift first as the rope is pulled?
by RiderOfGiraffes on Friday September 03, 2010 @11:35AM
(#1659900)
Do you really want me to write the full six page analysis? No, I didn't think so. Unfortunately, concise replies such as the one I gave and which require the reader to think a little often result in replies such as yours where it is difficult to discern whether you are being deliberately clever, deliberately trollish, or genuinely confused.
Let me expand.
I only assumed the weights were unsupported, not the man. I did that to assist the reader in understanding the analysis. I did not assume the man was unsupported - I had hoped my initial description of what happens implied that. Possibly it didn't.
I would expect that the problem is intended to include the floor - that's not my point. Having made the analysis for the unsupported weights, the evolution of the situation when there is a floor becomes obvious.
So I hope you were joking, and not a troll.
Re:Which weight will lift first as the rope is pulled?
by brlewis on Friday September 03, 2010 @12:18PM
(#1660075)
I'm not trolling, and only half joking. Your first paragraph where you talked about the heavier weight falling seemed like a joke about the drawing not including a floor. Which would be fine, except someone making that silly assumption should go all the way with it and assume the man is unsupported too.
Now I understand that you were helping people understand the analysis, and I'm sorry my reply sounded trollish.
Re:Which weight will lift first as the rope is pulled?
by henrikschroder on Friday September 03, 2010 @04:05PM
(#1660926)
Not if he weighs less than 60kg. :-)