Re:Safe-money: Money in the type system where it belongs (2017)
by abiox on Thursday March 15, 2018 @03:04PM
(#16595628)
1) "The value of a currency is the effort required to obtain it"
2) (Inheritance requires no or marginal effort in acquisition)
c) "Inheritance is worthless, then."
Re:Safe-money: Money in the type system where it belongs (2017)
by btilly on Thursday March 15, 2018 @04:07PM
(#16596136)
Modify #1 to "The value of the currency is the average effort required to obtain X in wealth."
That allows us to include inheritance of wealth and finding bags of gold in the street without dismantling our understanding that a given amount of money represents a given amount of effort that we can expect others to be willing to exert to acquire that money from us.
And then walk through a house and look at it not as $X00,000 dollars, but rather as the amount of human work it represents.
Re:Safe-money: Money in the type system where it belongs (2017)
by RandComment on Thursday March 15, 2018 @04:27PM
(#16596248)
Currency value isn't dependent on a single entity's experience or the starving man would set food prices. SMH
Re:Safe-money: Money in the type system where it belongs (2017)
by abiox on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:16PM
(#16598090)
presumably your issue was with the first premise and not the conclusion.
Re:Safe-money: Money in the type system where it belongs (2017)
by RandComment on Friday March 16, 2018 @03:37PM
(#16603422)
That is not presumed. Reappropriating how value and effort are measured is just raising strawmen, as I intimated.
Re:Safe-money: Money in the type system where it belongs (2017)
by abiox on Friday March 16, 2018 @03:47PM
(#16603513)
then your post was purely non-sequitur, as the syllogism's conclusion holds. there was no strawman.
Re:Safe-money: Money in the type system where it belongs (2017)
by RandComment on Friday March 16, 2018 @04:00PM
(#16603610)
> purely non-sequitur
That's projection. No definition was offered and the existing was discounted. Still a strawman. Good luck with whatever.
That's a spurious deduction. Inheritance is a mechanism of passing value store. Purely living off inheritance, reduces the stored value. This is a demonstration of the concept, not a violation.