But the fact there is no scrobbling of played music? That's just silly, what on earth were they thinking? O.o
Honestly, I'd like to know, can ANYONE explain that?
EDIT: The top 10 pop chart artists all seem to have around 100k followers, will be interesting to see how it goes.
iTunes could satisfy the iTunes user market. But unless clusters of friends all use iTunes, a decentralized service will be more useful. And i'm not sure if being an itunes user means more of your friends use itunes (to any level of significancy). So chances are most people will have a bunch of friends who can't participate.
Apple do what they always do.
Not everything that is possible only what is necessary.
Apple have entered the social space, it's official, people will now know.
Then they will improve on it step by step.
It's obvious that the problems with facebook integration is also affecting our perception a great deal.
The only thing I can think of is that reviewing or purchasing through ITMS requires more active engagement, instead of the more passive scrobbling. Of course this engagement requires more effort, but they want people to purchase through iTunes and review things in ITMS anyway, perhaps they like to provide an extra incentive to do so, and at the same time make you more loyal to ITMS instead of other competitive music stores online?
I'm not sure I would've made the same decision (realizing that people are lazy by nature and want their music profile to be built automatically), but these are the only arguments I can think of.
A lot of people are going to want to present a different music profile than their actual listening habits.
Social networks sell themselves to users based on what the users can share and display about themselves to their social network. The more that a user can shape his persona (by revealing different information) the more appealing a social network will be to users, a big reason why facebook is so popular is exactly for this reason: it allows you to shape your presence in a very varied way (this is why pages is a killer feature).
To describe ping, apple should have really said that its a social network for ITMS, not a social network for music.
Someone's profile:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/pdp/profile/A2KEKKJ9CAC2KC/
Communities home page:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/tagging/communities/directory
Music community home page:
http://www.amazon.com/communities/directory/music/ref=tag_td...
A people affinity page, in this case, cats:
http://www.amazon.com/tag/cats/people/ref=tag_cdp_bkt_icus
Agree with your point that for now "it's a social network for ITMS". Seems a better way of thinking about it, and dovetails with defaulting to off and using ITMS account (a can of worms).
ADDED: When you're Apple, it's true you can't really afford a classic MVP. That doesn't mean perfectionism, it means that although you release something limited, you add in something great that's never been done before. The iPhone was the first phone with a multitouch interface. Plenty of people are willing to overlook not having picture messaging, or 3G, or third party apps for something that great. But you have to do something awesome and new--you can't just rehash the rest of the market.
Let me ask my friends on Buzz...
They could use Genius data... which then makes me wonder why they didn't.
For comparison I found Muse had a stream on Ping so I checked it compared to their Twitter account. Ping's stream for them was sanitized and small. It was not personal and I assume it didn't tell me anything other than what the label wanted me to know.
With full access to my very large library including many albums purchased in ITMS, they suggested a series of artists I have no interest in.
Activity is only measured by what you purchase or review in the ITMS, not on what I actually do in iTunes. They have an opportunity to steal everyones lunch with Ping. Mirroring last.fm functionality with scrobbling and then presenting that info in the profile is a no-brainer.
When looking at my profile, I noticed that the two things it pointed as were two reviews I made in iTunes from years ago. Fresh content is king.
The interface is terrible. Navigating around Ping is a mess.
Granted this is a 1.0, but they have a lot of work to do if they want it to get serious traction and they need to loosen the content reigns a bit. Waiting for my profile pic to be approved is silly.