News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Simplicity Is Highly Overrated by riffraff on Friday September 03, 2010 @06:29AM (#1659103)
this was my first thought too (and there are plenty of washing machines with a couple of buttons and the rest hidden behind a panel to prove it, I thought).

But this is also addressed in the article, in the addendum part:

""" One person truly misunderstood because he advocated hiding the extra controls, thus preserving the apparent simplicity. Sorry: it is the apparent complexity that drives the sale. """

Re:Simplicity Is Highly Overrated by jacquesm on Friday September 03, 2010 @06:40AM (#1659121)
> Sorry: it is the apparent complexity that drives the sale.

Maybe that holds true for some applications, but for the most part (in my experience at least) 'hiding' is not synonymous with 'having the right stuff at the right time'.

To make your application appear complex is just going to increase the barrier to entry.

I'm fairly sure the only reason I'm in business and have been for a long time is because the first contact with our application is as simple as you could possibly make it.

That it can do a lot of other stuff is assumed until needed. People sometimes send support mail about very advanced features indicating that the 'power users' are definitely able to find their way. But for 99% of the audience the first level is all they'll ever get to and they're happy there.

If you sell a luxury car, apparently it has to have buttons.

But when you look at those buttons on a 10 year old car you'll see which ones are the ones that got used (because they wore!). As a rules, it's the same buttons that you'll find on a Lada.

But cars are 'conspicuous consumption' for some, so they are not to be compared with a web-app.

Something like 'mint' has enormous functionality but they've made it relatively (as easy as you can make it I guess) easy to get on board because of this exposure trick.

Good software uses context. Over-complex design does not drive sales unless you're trying to send all your competitors down a dead end street.

Microsoft word, that pinnacle of design, is only where it is today because of lock-in, if not for that (users emailing each other word documents) and some pretty ruthless marketing it wouldn't stand a chance.

Text editing is - as someone quoted here - a solved problem, but it seems that there still isn't an easy way to get what you want. Possibly there will never be (because text editing is inherently complex), but that should not discourage those that seek to enhance the user experience with minimalist approaches.

To me the apple audio line of products is a great example of how minimal + gradual exposure is the way to enormous sales, don't forget they weren't the first company to produce an audio player (or a smartphone either).

Re:Simplicity Is Highly Overrated by michael_dorfman on Friday September 03, 2010 @06:47AM (#1659135)
To make your application appear complex is just going to increase the barrier to entry.

That depends on the customer segment you are targeting.

Over-complex design does not drive sales unless you're trying to send all your competitors down a dead end street.

Or, if you're selling "Enterprise Software". I've had to re-design things to be less simple, in order to make them more attractive to customers, and had my staff spend countless hours developing bells and whistles that impressed purchasing VPs in demos, but then were never used by the actual users.

Some customers will take "more features, and a busier looking interface" over "a simple, elegant design that actually does everything you need it to" every time. In my experience, these tend to be the customers who are not users themselves-- but, they often have the purchasing power over thousands of users.

Re:Simplicity Is Highly Overrated by jacquesm on Friday September 03, 2010 @07:14AM (#1659188)
That's kind of the point right? When end users do not drive sales you are likely right, as your experience indicates. But when end users do drive sales (and for most of us here that's day to day life) then a clean interface is key.

B2B is different in this respect than B2C, and conspicuous consumption is different from both of those still.

Re:Simplicity Is Highly Overrated by akshayubhat on Friday September 03, 2010 @07:18AM (#1659196)

      but then were never used by the actual users
That's fine, The last thing VP's or management want is an employees coming to them and telling how they "can't" do something due to lack of a feature.

Cost of not getting a job done due to lack of a feature is very high compared to cost of adding that feature. And cost of adding a new feature only when a need arises is even higher.

It is hard to predict which feature you will actually need over course of time, thus the safest bet is to have as many reasonable features as possible.

Re:Simplicity Is Highly Overrated by kenjackson on Friday September 03, 2010 @01:43PM (#1660393)
I think the OP misunderstands what drives the sale in these cases. It's not apparent complexity, its apparent functionality.

The problem is that the way to make functionality apparent at the point of sale is to expose it, hence the complexity. But I think as people begin to realize that functionality can lie beneath the surface, as Zed points out, you'll see simplicity with high functionality become more popular.